What Ontario employees working from home need to know about time theft
Experts are warning that electronic tracking and monitoring of remote employees in Ontario could be used by companies as evidence of time theft.
Time theft, a broad term used to describe incidents in which an employee says they are working when they are not, is not an idea exclusive to remote work.
Examples include asking a co-worker to log in while the employee is not in the office or an instance in which an employee says they are on a job site but is actually elsewhere.
But as remote work remains popular, experts say there may be more cases of companies taking employees to court.
‘A CRAZY PRECEDENT’
Earlier this month, a British Columbia accountant was ordered to repay $1,500 to her employers after being found guilty of time theft.
In this particular case, the employee sued the company for wrongful termination. The company then countersued, claiming there were about 50 unaccounted hours recorded on the employees timesheets.
“Time theft in the employment context is viewed as a very serious form of misconduct,” the Civil Resolution Tribunal’s decision, dated Jan. 11, read.
“Given that trust and honesty are essential to an employment relationship, particularly in a remote-work environment where direct supervision is absent, I find (the employee’s) misconduct led to an irreparable breakdown in her employment relationship with (her employer) and that dismissal was proportionate in the circumstances.”
Nita Chhinzer, an associate professor at the University of Guelph’s department of management, told CTV News Toronto this case sets a “crazy precedent,” in which an employee’s performance is based solely on their ability to fit eight hours of work into a day.
“This isn't the first time that we're hearing about time theft, but it is one of the first times in which we're seeing the company provide evidence of the time theft because they were using electronic monitoring to determine when the individual was at work and when they weren't,” she said.
“It brings forward this archaic idea that everyone should be measured based on how many hours they work.”
- Download our app to get local alerts on your device
- Get the latest local updates right to your inbox
Sundeep Gokhale, an employment lawyer with Sherrard Kuzz LLP, told CTV News Toronto it's normal for time theft to be a consideration when terminating a worker with just cause. Although he says in the case of remote work, it will likely be very specific to the employee’s circumstances.
He said employers will have to provide opportunities to explain inactivity, warning that someone could be reading a printed report, for example, and the tracking technologies may not reflect that work.
“It's not going to be something that an employer can rely on carte blanche,” Gokhale said. “I think it can be part of an investigation, part of an inquiry into whether or not there was time theft or not.”
Remote work has significantly increased in popularity since the COVID-19 pandemic. One October 2022 survey found that 80 per cent of Canadian remote workers would quit their jobs if their employers asked them to return to the office five days a week.
As a result, there is a necessity for employers to have greater trust in their employees while they are working at home.
“The courts are very cognizant that there's not a supervisor there,” Dave McKechnie, a partner at McMillan LLP, who specializes in employment law, told CTV News Toronto.
“I think you will see more of these cases coming, probably, in the coming year or two.”
File photo of man in pajamas working. (gpointstudio/Shutterstock)
At the same time, McKechnie argues an employer will have to prove the time spent away from work is significantly different than what an employee would experience while in the office. Simply scrolling through social media for five minutes, for example, wouldn’t be grounds for time theft, he said.
NEW TRANSPARENCY RULES IN ONTARIO
Last year, the Ontario government passed a law that requires companies with 25 or more employees to create a written policy outlining whether or not they were using computers, cellphones, GPS systems and other electronic devices to track their workers. The policy must include a description of how the employer may electronically monitor its employees and the purposes for which the information may be used.
Companies are expected to update the policy every year, beginning in 2023.
The requirement was part of a broader piece of legislation–called the “Working for Workers Act”—that also asked companies to craft policies detailing their employees’ rights to disconnect outside of business hours.
Gokhale says the legislation ensures employees are aware of and understand how their employers are monitoring their work.
“That's really the benefit of that legislation is that (it) takes away any type of confusion or uncertainty about whether or not something is being monitored or not.”
These types of tracking technologies can vary depending on the company. In some instances, employees may be asked to use a system that measures keystrokes or mouse activity, while others may be asked to use an internal system to manually log their progress.
“It takes away a potential claim from the employee that they didn't know,” McKechnie said. “I think courts and tribunals are not receptive to employee claims where they say they've been terminated unjustly when the employer can prove time theft,” he said.
“If it's clear that the employee is not working, period, or working for somebody else–and we're seeing a lot of that in the working from home scenario–or you're not present at their desk during normal business hours when they should be, then you're going see a lot of those for-cause cases coming through the pipeline.”
Chhinzer says that while the new legislation does inform employees of how and why they are being monitored, it does not going into detail about what companies are allowed to track.
“It says you're enabled to use any monitoring you think is sufficient for your workplace. You just have to be able to you have to explain and defend that choice to your employees.”
This kind of information is useful in not only finding evidence of time theft, but also ensuring equity among employees, Chhinzer added.
She also hopes that electronic monitoring, while problematic in some circumstances, can also help employers realize their fears surrounding productivity and remote work are unfounded.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Three dead, two hospitalized, following collision in Fredericton: police
Three people have died and two have been hospitalized after a speeding car struck a tree and landed on another vehicle in Fredericton Sunday morning.
Nylander defends Leafs' core after playoff exit, Toronto again picks up the pieces
The Maple Leafs battled back from a 3-1 series deficit against the Boston Bruins with consecutive 2-1 victories - including one that required extra time - in their first-round playoff series to push the club's Original Six rival to the limit before suffering a devastating Game 7 overtime loss.
Amid climate change warnings, Canadians lukewarm on electric vehicles
Amid scientists' warnings that nations need to transition away from fossil fuels to limit climate change, Canadians are still lukewarm on electric vehicles, according to a study conducted by Nanos Research for CTV News.
Montreal man on the hook for thousands of dollars after a feature on his Tesla caused an accident
A Montreal man is warning Tesla drivers about using the Smart Summon feature after his vehicle hit another in a parking lot.
Madonna's biggest-ever concert transforms Rio's Copacabana beach into a massive dance floor
Madonna put on a free concert on Copacabana beach Saturday night, turning Rio de Janeiro's vast stretch of sand into an enormous dance floor teeming with a multitude of her fans.
Mexican authorities say thieves killed 2 Australians and an American to steal their truck
Thieves killed two Australians and an American on a surfing trip to Mexico in order to steal their truck, particularly because they wanted the tires, authorities said Sunday.
1 person killed and 23 injured in a bus crash in northern Maryland, police say
One person was killed and 23 others were injured when a bus crashed early Sunday on Interstate 95 in northern Maryland, police said.
El Nino weakening doesn't mean cooler temperatures this summer, forecasters say
As Canadians brace themselves for summer temperatures, forecasters say a weakening El Nino cycle doesn’t mean relief from the heat.
‘Love has no boundaries’: Sask. couple in their 90s and 80s get married
Eighty-two-year-old Susan Neufeldt and 90-year-old Ulrich Richter are no spring chickens, but their love blossomed over the weekend with their wedding at Pine View Manor just outside of Rosthern.