Ontario councillor receives 60-day pay suspension
CORRECTION: A previous version of this story failed to adequately capture the exact nature of the motions that were tabled by the councillor. The story also did not make clear that the quotes attributed to the councillor in the integrity commissioner’s report were actually paraphrases of the councillor’s notices of motion by the integrity commissioner. CTV News Toronto apologizes for any confusion.
Pickering Coun. Lisa Robinson has received another pay suspension due to conduct the city’s integrity commissioner says amounted to “homophobic and transphobic behaviour.”
Robinson made headlines last month when she compared her first 30-day pay suspension – a demerit she received due to alleged bullying in her community – to “modern-day slavery.”
This month’s pay cut, a 60-day wage suspension, follows complaints filed to the city’s integrity commissioner about Robinson’s conduct at a Durham District School Board meeting in May.
According to council minutes dated Oct. 23, Robinson attended the school board meeting and, using a bullhorn microphone, addressed a “large and occasionally unruly” crowd about motions she intended to bring to council the following week.
The first of those motions called for only “federal, provincial and municipal flags to be permitted to be raised in all public spaces,” with an exception to also allow the Poppy flag and Veterans flag. It stated that by allowing “non-government flags” the city would effectively be “favouring one group over another.”
The second motion took aim at drag shows and pride parades, stating that both amount to “adult live performances.” That motion called for Pickering to prohibit “a person from knowingly admitting a child” to such an event, and if “any licensed public lodging or public food service establishment” violates that policy, they should have their license “suspended or revoked.”
The third motion concerned the co-ed change room at Chestnut Hill Recreation Complex, which she charged “gives an opportunity for predators to be alone with vulnerable children.” Robinson stated in the motion that in order to “minimize the risks of predators preying [sic] on children who are not accompanied by an adult,” the members’ only male and female change rooms should be made available to all individuals of the corresponding genders. Robinson said that the co-ed changeroom could be “inclusive to all genders and or families.”
In her report, the integrity commissioner found that in making the remarks Robinson “promoted attitudes which are homophobic and transphobic.” It also found that the motions she attempted to bring forward “would not withstand scrutiny under Ontario’s Human Rights Code.”
“Whether it is the targeted removal of the flag raising opportunity from the LGBTQ2S+ community, the targeted prohibition of pride parades, banning drag queens from engaging in story-reading to children at the library, or implying that gender-neutral change rooms are in any way putting children at risk, we find the councillor’s conduct in promoting the motions on the steps of the DDSB office to constitute homophobic and transphobic behaviour,” the report notes.
In her report, the integrity commissioner found there had been no allegations of "predators alone with vulnerable children" inside coed change rooms, as Robinson had suggested in her remarks at the DDSB.
With regards to the second motion concerning some pride events, the integrity commissioner said that while Robinson framed it in terms of “drag shows” it “clearly targets drag queen story time along with pride parades.” The integrity commissioner went on to say that Robinson has “never been to see a drag queen story time,” and that she made inaccurate comments about “gyrating and shaking” during these events citing only her personal experience at traditional drag shows.
The integrity commissioner did acknowledge in her report that Robinson’s remarks did not contain ‘hateful rhetoric’ or amount to ‘hate speech.”
But said that her suggestion that she was “merely reflecting the views of her constituents” should not excuse the conduct.
“This cannot justify positions publicly stated which must be seen as contrary to Human Rights protected positions,” the report notes.
In a post to her personal Facebook page, Robinson called the findings “disconcerning” [sic], saying the City of Pickering “actively exacerbates the divide among individuals who are peacefully protesting for opposing views.”
“This deliberate action of fueling the fire only serves two [sic] deepen the existing divisions within society,” she said.
Correction
CORRECTION: A previous version of this story failed to adequately capture the exact nature of the motions that were tabled by the councillor. The story also did not make clear that the quotes attributed to the councillor in the integrity commissioner’s report were actually paraphrases of the councillor’s notices of motion by the integrity commissioner. CTV News Toronto apologizes for any confusion.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Hezbollah confirms its leader Hassan Nasrallah was killed in an Israeli airstrike
Lebanon's Hezbollah group confirmed on Saturday that its leader and one of its founders, Hassan Nasrallah, was killed in an Israeli airstrike in Beirut the previous day
LGBTQ2S+ minister Pascale St-Onge to make history with parental leave
Canadian Heritage Minister Pascale St-Onge is set to make history by becoming the first openly lesbian cabinet minister to take parental leave when her wife gives birth in the coming weeks.
At least 52 dead and millions without power after Helene's deadly march across southeastern U.S.
Hurricane Helene caused at least 52 deaths and billions of dollars of destruction across a wide swath of the southeastern U.S. as it raced through, and more than three million customers went into the weekend without any power and for some a continued threat of floods.
'Imagine a world without their song': Toronto photographer wins international award for picture of 4,000 dead birds
Thousands of dead birds, from kingfishers to blue jays, encircle a wild turkey to illustrate in one snapshot a mere fragment of how many die from colliding into glass windows – a death that can be easily prevented, the Torontonian photographer says.
Police swarm home after man allegedly confronts snowmobile owner with crossbow
Several heavily armed officers descended on a home in the southeast area of Barrie Thursday afternoon after reports of a man armed with a crossbow.
Northern Ont. group fined $8,500 for moose hunt violations
Four hunters from Ear Falls west of Thunder Bay, Ont., have been fined for an illegal moose hunt in October 2022 and two of them lost their hunting licence for multiple years.
Jury awards US$300 million to women who alleged sex abuse by doctor at a Virginia children's hospital
A jury has ruled in favor of three women who alleged they were sexually abused while patients at a Virginia children's hospital, awarding them a total of US$300 million in damages.
Russian strikes on a medical centre kill 9 people in the Ukrainian city of Sumy
Two consecutive Russian attacks on a medical centre in the northeastern Ukrainian city of Sumy on Saturday killed at least nine people, officials said.
'This was her life': Owner of Sask. restaurant destroyed in fire plans to restart
In the aftermath of a fire that destroyed Snow White Family Restaurant in Biggar Saskatchewan, a GoFundMe has been created to help the owner start over.