Speed cameras clocked a car driving 70 km/h over the limit. Here's how the owner fought the ticket and won
Speed cameras clocked a car driving 70 km/h over the limit. Here's how the owner fought the ticket and won
An Ontario speed limit sign is seen above on Wednesday, March 17, 2021. (CTV News)
After being charged with speeding by a city-operated photo radar device, a Toronto family was able to successfully fight the charge in court largely due to one small detail.
The driver, identified in court proceedings as Blayne Kumar, was captured by an automated speed enforcement (ASE) camera driving on Avenue Rd. just after 3 a.m. on Aug. 15, 2021.
Kumar, 35, was driving to his girlfriend’s residence, when court documents claim the ASE camera registered his speed at approximately 121 km/h – 71 km/h over the posted speed limit.
Facing a $1,400 fine, Kumar challenged the ticket – and won.
In December, the Ontario Court of Justice dismissed the charge, with Justice of the Peace Roger Rodrigues stating the prosecution could not, beyond a reasonable doubt, prove Kumar had been travelling 121 km/h.
"When I consider the defendant's exculpatory evidence, which was not in any way shaken through cross-examination, in the context of the collective effect or nature of the frailties in the prosecution’s evidence [...], I am left with a reasonable doubt as to the defendant’s guilt,” Rodrigues said in the decision.
Kumar’s defence and subsequent victory hinged on one factor: whether the ASE camera that clocked his alleged speed was in reliable working condition. When cross-examined, the prosecution was unable to prove the accuracy and routine maintenance of the camera.
While the City of Toronto maintains the accuracy and reliability of its photo radar program, legal experts say Kumar’s case could pave a path to precedence for future ASE ticket challenges.
THE CASE
When a ticket is automatically issued by an ASE camera, it is done so in the name of the owner of the car. ASE cameras are unable to distinguish or identify drivers of vehicles. As with all ASE offences, the potential consequences are solely monetary.
In turn, it was Kumar’s mother, Ooma Ramroop, who was named as a defendant in the case, documents show.
According to the decision, during Kumar's testimony, he maintained he never drove in excess of 50 km/h on the August evening. He testified that he often drives on Avenue Road and therefore was aware of the “speed trap” recently installed. Because of this, Kumar testified he “always” set the vehicle’s cruise control to “47 or 48 km/h” when turning onto the roadway.
Kumar also told the court that, as a driver since the age of 16 years old, he knows what a speed of 121 km/hour “feels like.”
David Powers, the officer who certified the ASE photograph resulting in Kumar’s charge, also testified, stating that the vehicle’s licence plate was clearly visible in the image produced by the ASE camera and that the camera's readout showed a speed of 121 km/h.
However, when Powers was cross-examined by the defence and questioned on the device’s installation and maintenance, he was unable to provide sufficient and necessary context.
Documents state Powers was unable to name which company was responsible for certifying the accuracy of the camera in question, or when the camera had last been tested for accuracy. By law, each device has to be calibrated within 12 months before an alleged offence.
Nowhere in the decision does it indicate that a certificate of accuracy for the ASE camera that issued Kumar a ticket was presented as evidence in court. The city lists these certificates for each camera on its website.
During the cross-examination, documents state Powers also erroneously claimed that in the photograph captured of Ramroop’s vehicle, only one vehicle was present when, in fact, there were two vehicles visible.
In turn, Rodrigues wrote in his decision that the officer’s cross-examination “materially lessened” the strength of his evidence, while Kumar’s testimony “contained adequate detail to be considered plausible," and determined that the prosecution had failed to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the vehicle had been speeding.
The City of Toronto is currently reviewing the decision, it said in an emailed statement to CTV News Toronto.
“In the meantime, it is important to understand every case is adjudicated on its own merits and an acquittal in this case in no way means Toronto’s ASE system is not accurate or reliable,” the statement read.
A PRECEDENT?
When reached for comment, paralegal Paul Periti, representation for Ramroop, told CTV News Toronto said he believes he “brought some doubt to the prosecution’s case through cross-examination,” but that the bulk of the doubt came simply from the driver’s testimony.
“The defendant's son who was driving the vehicle denied the accused rate of speed and described very eloquently how fast he was travelling,” he said.
Dylan Finlay, trial lawyer at Oykhman Criminal Defence in Toronto, told CTV News Toronto Friday that Kumar’s case could lay a path for future ASE court challenges.
“I don’t think it’s a new loophole,” Finlay said.
“But yes, the questions [the officer] was asked, and what he was shaken on, certainly lays a path for other people challenging tickets in the future.”
While Periti said he cannot comment on the “overall reliability” of the city’s ASE cameras, he said he is wary of the system and questions whether it prioritizes profits over safety.
For years, the city has been moving away from ASE ticket challenges being heard in court, and instead towards administrative penalty tribunals, which are headed by hearing officers rather than judges. The move is meant to free up the court system and alleviate backlogs, the city said.
But Periti disavows this decision, claiming it infringes upon Ontarian’s right to fight such charges in a court of law.
“It [can] become an accusation and just pay with no opportunity to go before the unbiased Judiciary in this province – you appeal to the city who accused you,” he explained.
On Feb. 2, while revealing the locations of 25 new ASE cameras across the city, Toronto Mayor John Tory reiterated that the program's top priority is road safety, and stated that the cameras have been successful in lowering some driver’s speeds.
U.S. President Joe Biden arrived Thursday evening in Ottawa for a whirlwind 27-hour visit expected to focus on both the friendly and thorny aspects of the Canada-U.S. relationship, including protectionism and migration on both sides of the border.
Canada and the United States are negotiating a deal that could see asylum seekers turned back at irregular border crossings across the border, including Roxham Road in Quebec.
As the federal government looks to renegotiate the Safe Third Country Agreement with the U.S., an eastern Ontario mayor says his city needs more help from Ottawa to deal with the influx of asylum seekers arriving through irregular crossings like Roxham Road.
Amid renewed questions over the pervasiveness of alleged interference by China in Canadian elections and affairs broadly, opposition MPs voted Thursday afternoon to affirm a parliamentary committee's call for the federal government to strike a public inquiry.
A majority of Canadians have seen a mistake on their grocery receipts in the last year, according to a new survey conducted by Agri-Food Analytics Lab at Dalhousie University.
An asteroid discovered just last week will pass closer to the Earth than the orbit of the moon this weekend, an occurrence so rare it happens only once in a decade, according to NASA.
The number of Canadians receiving employment insurance benefits are at record lows and down 44 per cent from last year, new figures from Statistics Canada show.
Two Kanien'keha:ka (Mohawk) sisters from Montreal are on a mission that is close to their hearts: to save their ancestors' first language by developing video games young and old can play.
For the first time, the owner of a building in Old Montreal has responded to questions about the fire — through his lawyer — addressing allegations that the building was unsafe.
The political class at the National Assembly has condemned the 'violent' and 'hateful' remarks that columnist Gilles Proulx allegedly made about Quebec solidaire MNAs during Richard Martineau's show on Qub radio in recent weeks.
The new provincial budget features items specific to southwestern Ontario, including a new English public elementary school in London, Ont. that will serve 556 students and include 88 licensed childcare spaces.
A young Strathroy, Ont. man believes there's a promising way forward in the effort to fight his disease. But, he's being told, right now, that path isn't open to him. Friends and family are stepping up to try and make a case for Kyle McPhee to receive immunotherapy treatments.
The ‘Catch the Ace’ jackpot is still up for grabs in Hagersville. There was no winner Thursday night so the total prize money is now an estimated $1,526,067.
The resurrection of Zellers is officially underway with the Cambridge location opening its doors to eager shoppers who lined up ahead of the store's official reopening.
The co-owners of a new liquidation store in North Bay, Samuel Quesnel and Chloé Boivenue, say they want to bring a treasure hunt shopping experience to the city.
U.S. President Joe Biden arrived Thursday evening in Ottawa for a whirlwind 27-hour visit expected to focus on both the friendly and thorny aspects of the Canada-U.S. relationship, including protectionism and migration on both sides of the border.
Emergency crews responded to a call for a stabbing on Hartsmere Drive, off Stittsville Main Street, at approximately 7:45 p.m. Thursday. Two police cruisers guarded the parking lot of the Trustee M. Curry Park late Thursday evening.
The Conseil des écoles catholiques du Centre-Est has announced plans for a four-day school week pilot-project this fall, becoming the first school board in Ontario to offer families a shortened school week schedule.
After a year-and-a-half without, the Windsor-Essex County Health Unit (WECHU) says it’s narrowing in on hiring a permanent chief medical officer of health.
When the permit to construct a replacement span for the Ambassador Bridge expired in the summer of 2022, many thought that would bring an end to a 20-year saga of boarded up homes in the city’s west end.
The quick thinking and immediate actions of two people are credited with possibly saving the life of a Midland councillor after he collapsed at a meeting Wednesday evening.
Investigators with York Regional Police issued Canada-wide warrants for two men who they say are involved in the Richmond Hill attack on Ontario woman Elnaz Hajtamiri weeks before she was allegedly abducted.
The Tim Houston PC government remains firm in their promise they'll fix the health-care system by spending more taxpayer money on health than any previous government before.
Potato farmers on Prince Edward Island are taking the federal government to court due to the decision to restrict the movement of P.E.I. seed potatoes.
The Alberta Energy Regulator has cited an energy company for causing a series of earthquakes, including the largest recorded tremblor in the province's history.
Manitoba First Nation police have arrested a man connected with a shooting on March 19 on Long Plain First Nation that resulted in the community going on lockdown.
Manitoba’s labour force is growing at a rate to supply enough workers for available positions into 2026, according to the province’s labour market outlook.
Following a court appearance Thursday, a B.C. woman facing more than 20 charges – including manslaughter – in connection with alleged druggings of men who used escort services was remanded into custody.
The man killed in West Vancouver earlier this week was a retired urologist who was involved in several legal disputes over valuable real estate, CTV News has learned.
The Alberta Energy Regulator has cited an energy company for causing a series of earthquakes, including the largest recorded tremblor in the province's history.
An Ontario speed limit sign is seen above on Wednesday, March 17, 2021. (CTV News)
