Ontario woman says she was sold 'crumbling' house despite home inspection
As Kim Sandford put away her China dishes after Christmas dinner in 2018, she noticed her cabinet doors refused to shut.
Sandford, a 59-year-old retired nurse from a small community near Kawartha Lakes, didn’t think much of it at the time, but would soon learn the problem ran deep.
Her house, she told CTV News Toronto, was sloping and sinking into the ground.
Now six years later, Sandford said she’s drained her savings in a legal pursuit to hold the former owner and home inspector responsible for what she claims was an attempt to hide the home’s crumbling foundation.
“It’s completely taken everything we have,” Sandford said. “We’re in debt. We have no savings left. We’ve gone without food to pay bills.”
In the summer of 2018, Sandford and her husband bought the three-bedroom century-old house in the Kawarthas for $285,000.
Before making the purchase, they hired a home inspector to examine the property. He produced a 46-page report which found the structure to be in compliance with the Ontario Association of Home Inspectors standards of practice.
Though Sandford didn’t know it at the time, her faulty cabinets were only the beginning of her troubles. In the months that followed, she said she started having to wrap herself in an electric blanket to get through the winter. No matter how high she turned her furnace, heat continued to escape the home.
Frustrated, Sandford’s husband soon descended to the basement in search of the issue.
He cut a small hole in what he believed to be an exterior wall, but instead, discovered an opening into the home’s foundation, filled with crumbling rubble and boulders.
An opening cut in a wood panel showing the collapsed stone rubble foundation behind the wood panel, according to an engineer's report.
“You could tell once upon a time it was a wall,” Sandford said. “It was supposed to be holding up the house.” The two storeys above are essentially airborne, she said.
On the other side of the basement wall, beneath a deck that wrapped around the house, he also found a gaping hole where the brutal breeze gust inside, she said. “You could walk right in,” Sandford added.
An engineer’s report conducted in June 2022 to determine the extent of the damage showed photographs of a “collapsed” and “dangling” stone rubble foundation “sloping” inward.
“It’s like a seesaw with no weight on one side,” Sandford said.
View inside of wood frame after engineers removed metal panel. When reached for comment, the former owners said they could not discuss the matter while it was before the courts, but pointed to a statement of defence dated July 2021, which claims the home was sold on an “as-is” basis.
The former owners never lived in the home, the claim states, and instead rented it out to tenants after purchasing it in 2011. In the statement, they maintain they made no attempt to “fraudulently or negligently conceal” any issues with the home, and that the wall in question pre-dated their ownership.
The claim says the contract stated the buyer would be responsible for repair costs after closing, and that the listing had communicated the home needed work, with tenants reporting moisture in the basement and garage.
An engineer measuring the slope of inward movement of the stone rubble foundation.While the MLS listing did say the home would be sold on an “as-is” basis, Sandford said the actual contract of purchase made no such mention.
One of the core principles of real estate law can be summarized by the phrase “buyer beware,” says Bob Aaron, a Toronto real estate lawyer independent of the proceedings.
Simply put, buyers make purchases at their own risk.
Unless the sellers knew and hid defects that made the property dangerous or uninhabitable, they are under no obligation to disclose anything to the buyer, Aaron added.
“They are going to have to prove that there was a misrepresentation,” he said.
When it comes to home inspecting, he added that it’s not an examiner’s job to rip out walls and uncover deficiencies with a house, but rather, the process is observational, and nonintrusive. The company Sandford hired did not respond to requests from CTV News Toronto.
“Home inspectors inspect what they see, they don’t inspect what they can’t see,” Aaron said.
While Sandford’s legal action continues, so does a lingering fear that her house will one day crumble completely. She still loves her home, but feels it’s no longer a safe haven.
“You’re living in your stress. You can’t go to a safe spot, because the safe spot is your house,” Sandford said.
“I just want everyone to know that this can happen to them. This is how badly you can get burned.”
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Girl, 15, set on fire in assault at Saskatoon high school: police
A 15-year-old girl was set on fire in an assault at Saskatoon's Evan Hardy Collegiate Thursday afternoon, police say.
Liberal national campaign director says he will step down
Embattled Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and his governing Liberals have taken another hit with Jeremy Broadhurst quitting his job as national campaign director for the party.
Father of Georgia school shooting suspect arrested on charges including second-degree murder
The father of the teenager accused of opening fire at a Georgia high school, killing four people and wounding nine, has been arrested on various charges including second-degree murder, authorities said Thursday.
Toronto couple pushes for change after dog attacked by pack of coyotes
It started like any other night for Mary and Doug Youngson – a walk at their neighbourhood park with their rescue dogs, Mai Tai and Kahlua.
A Canadian airline is changing its check-in deadline for all flights. Here's why
Travellers will have to check in 15 minutes earlier than usual according to Air Canada's new cutoff time for all flights.
Man dies after surgeon removed wrong organ at Florida hospital, lawyer says
The lawyer of a woman whose husband died at a Florida hospital says the surgeon removed the wrong organ.
Conservative cuts? Party to share platform 'closer to the next election,' Scheer says
Conservative House Leader Andrew Scheer says Canadians will have to wait until 'closer' to the next federal election to learn about the party's platform.
Student convicted of killing classmate in Leduc gets life in prison without parole for 12 years
The man who fatally stabbed a classmate at his Leduc high school in 2021 was sentenced to life in prison with no parole eligibility for 12 years on Thursday.
BREAKING Murder, aggravated assault charges laid in Vancouver stranger attacks
Charges of murder and aggravated assault in a pair of brutal stranger attacks in downtown Vancouver were approved Thursday, one day after the rush-hour rampage left one man dead and another with a severed hand.