Ontario court dismisses MPP Sarah Jama's request for review of censure
An Ontario court has dismissed a request by MPP Sarah Jama for a judicial review of her censure from the legislature.
The May 23 decision found the courts have “no jurisdiction to review matters that fall within parliamentary privilege, including review under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.”
“The law is well-settled,” the decision says.
“As a matter of the constitutional separation of powers, those matters are within the exclusive purview of the Legislative Assembly.”
Jama was censured by the Doug Ford government in October over social media comments about the Israel-Gaza war. While a censure is typically a formal statement of disapproval, the government motion attached a condition that prevents the Speaker from recognizing her in the House until a formal apology is made.
Experts have called the motion “very rare,” as it prevents Jama from speaking publicly in the legislature on behalf of her constituents.
In a statement issued Tuesday, the Hamilton-Centre MPP reiterated that she will not apologize for her comments, in which expressed support for the Palestinian people and called for an end to the “occupation of Palestinian land.”
“With this disappointing decision the court is essentially stating that the Ontario Legislature can, with impunity, censor an elected opposition member with whom it disagrees,” Jama wrote.
“As I consider whether I have the energy and resources to appeal this decision, I continue to ask my fellow MPPs to do the right thing and vote to end my censure, if not because they have come to agree with my statements, then at least because they recognize that in a democratic country, I must have the right to make them.”
The Ontario Superior Court decision to dismiss the case focused solely on whether a judicial review is within its purview.
Government House Leader Paul Calandra said he is happy with the court’s decision, and that the government has “vigorously defended the important role of Parliament in our system of democracy.”
“This is the second time in recent years the courts have unequivocally upheld the supremacy of Parliament and I am very pleased with the outcome.”
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.6960772.1720740435!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.jpg)
Is there a solution to the rising cost of infant formula in Canada?
An Ontario mother says the increasing cost of baby formula for her seven month old is stressful. Since Samantha Krobel's child was born in November 2023, she says the cost of formula has gone up roughly $12.
One person in hospital after falling from swing ride at Canada's Wonderland
One person has been hospitalized after falling from a swing ride at Canada's Wonderland.
Tampons contain lead, arsenic and potentially toxic chemicals, studies say. Here's what to know
The average menstruating person will use an estimated 11,000 tampons, sanitary pads, panty liners and other menstrual products, experts say. What if some of those products contain heavy metals or potentially toxic chemicals?
Oilers star engaged to marry girlfriend after proposal in Spain
Edmonton Oilers superstar Leon Draisaitl is engaged to be married. The 28-year-old centre proposed to his girlfriend, actor Celeste Desjardins, who said yes. Both posted about the engagement Thursday to their Instagram accounts.
Biden pushes on 'blue wall' sprint with Michigan trip as he continues to make the case for candidacy
Joe Biden remains defiant that he'll remain in the U.S. presidential race despite a disastrous debate performance that triggered a wave of calls for him to end his candidacy.
Black bear 'wreaked havoc' on car after being locked inside, RCMP say
A black bear accidentally got locked in a car in Coquitlam Thursday, destroying the interior before being freed by police.
Number of Ontarians without family doctor reaches 2.5 million, college says
There are now 2.5 million people in Ontario who don't have a family doctor, the Ontario College of Family Physicians said on Thursday. That's an increase of more than 160,000 people since the last count was released six months ago, said Dr. Jobin Varughese, the incoming president of the college.
These Picassos prompted a gender war at an Australian gallery. Now the curator says she painted them
They were billed as artworks by Pablo Picasso, paintings so valuable that an Australian art museum’s decision to display them in an exhibition restricted to women visitors provoked a gender discrimination lawsuit. The paintings again prompted international headlines when the gallery re-hung them in a women’s restroom to sidestep a legal ruling that said men could not be barred from viewing them.
2 buses carrying more than 50 people were swept into a river by a landslide in Nepal
A landslide swept two passenger buses carrying more than 50 people into a swollen river in central Nepal early Friday, while continuous rain and more landslides were making rescue efforts difficult.