The Ontario Greenbelt decision: Who knew what and when?
A newly released auditor general report provides a glimpse into how the Ontario government decided to remove 7,400 acres of land from the Greenbelt and make it available to developers.
The findings show that a small handful of government staff were involved in the decision-making and that most of the recommendations were being funneled through the housing minister's chief of staff.
- Download our app to get local alerts on your device
- Get the latest local updates right to your inbox
Here is a breakdown of when the decisions were made and who was involved:
June 2022
Weeks after Doug Ford is re-elected as Premier of Ontario, his office presented the Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing with a mandate letter urging the ministry to “codify processes for swaps, expansions, contractions and policy updates for the Greenbelt.” The timeline for this goal was noted as the fall of 2022.
The mandate letter also included a “comprehensive plan to expand and protect the Greenbelt.”
July 2022
The Premier’s Office appoints Ryan Amato the chief of staff for the minister’s office.
August 2022
In early August, the Building Industry and Land Development Association (BILD) and the Ontario Home Builders’ Association released a plan to build new homes that specified the need for making “new land available.”
The premier’s daughter’s stag and doe party was held on Aug. 11. The integrity commissioner’s office noted that developers were among the list of attendees as they were friends of the Ford family. The premier has repeatedly said that no government business was discussed.
On Aug. 30, the housing ministry briefed the Amato on potential tools available to amend the Greenbelt.
September 2022
On Sept. 14, two prominent housing developers approached Amato at a BILD chair dinner and handed him packages with information on five sites on the Greenbelt.
The staffer told the auditor general that he did not open the packages at the dinner. Instead, he brought them to his office, where he put them on another stack of packages from developers and their representatives for further review.
These sites would eventually make up 92 per cent of the land removed from the Greenbelt.
On Sept. 15, a day later, a developer closed the purchase on the Greenbelt in King Township for about $80 million. Records show the property was sold to Green Lane Bathurst GP Inc., a company connected to developer Rice Group.
The following day, Clark’s chief of staff informed the housing ministry that the government wants to consult on removing lands from the Greenbelt using a site-specific approach, rather than evaluating the area as a whole. At this time, he provides three potential “priority” sites for review.
Ford’s daughter’s wedding takes place on Sept. 25 and developers were in attendance.
Between Sept. 27 and Sept. 29, a law firm sends multiple requests directly to the chief of staff regarding the removal of Greenbelt land and the rezoning of the Official Plan review of York Region.
October 2022
The six-person Greenbelt Project Team is formed between Oct. 3 and Oct. 5. They are provided with hardcopy packages on eight proposed sites as well as initial criteria for land removal.
Team members sign confidentiality agreements within the next few days.
Between Oct. 13 and Oct. 31, five USB keys are given to the Greenbelt Project Team by the chief of staff with information about proposed sites and previously identified sites.
On Oct. 25, the housing ministry posts a proposal notice on the Environmental Registry for public comment. The notice establishes policies for development in central Pickering and alters protections for the Duffins Rouge Agricultural Preserve.
The following day, the chair of the Greenbelt Council resigns and is replaced by the late Hazel McCallion, a long-time supporter of the Ford government.
Housing Minister Steve Clark is briefed by the Amato on the removal of land sites from the Greenbelt on Oct. 26.
Between Oct. 27 and Oct. 31, staff within the Premier’s office and cabinet office are briefed by the Ministry of Housing on two occasions.
November 2022
Housing Minister Steve Clark and Premier Doug Ford are both briefed by political staff on Nov. 1, a day before the proposal goes to cabinet.
Ontario Premier Doug Ford (left), and Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing Steve Clark (right), speak to the media during a press conference following the release of the Auditor General’s Special Report on Changes to the Greenbelt, at Queens Park, in Toronto, Wednesday, Aug. 9, 2023. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Arlyn McAdorey
On Nov. 3, before members of the public are told, developers are notified that land is being removed from the Greenbelt.
A broader briefing to caucus is provided on Nov. 4. This is when the government publicly reveals its intention to cut 7,400 acres of land and add an additional 9,400 acres to the Greenbelt. Mayors of affected municipalities are notified and a 30-day public notice is placed on the Environmental Registry. The Auditor General’s report noted that municipal elections were held in the end of October, meaning that some municipal councils were limited in their ability to comment on the proposal.
The Greenbelt Council, which provides advice to the minister on land use planning matters related to the protected land, is briefed on Nov. 7.
The following week, the province introduces the Duffins Rouge Agricultural Preserve Repeal Act, which proposed to remove additional development protections. The government exempts it from the public consultation process.
The More Homes Built Faster Act was passed on Nov. 28, the same day members of provincial parliament requested the integrity commissioner investigate whether the housing minister or premier contravened the Member’s Integrity Act.
December 2022
The Housing Minister and staff within the Premier’s Office is briefed by the ministry on the Greenbelt Project again on Dec. 12, days after the Duffins Rouge Agricultural Preserve Repeal Act passes.
On Dec. 21, the housing ministry posts a notice on the Environmental Registry saying the land removal has been finalized with no revisions.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Bomb cyclone batters B.C. with hurricane-force winds, cutting roads and power
Hurricane-force winds of up to 159 km/h have slammed into parts of the British Columbia coast as a massive storm swirling off Vancouver Island severed highways and cut power to about 225,000 people.
A 'lot of ground' remains between Canada Post, workers as strike talks progress
Canada Post and the postal workers union found slivers of consensus Tuesday amid talks with a special mediator, but 'a lot of ground' remains between them on the key concerns as a countrywide strike entered its fifth day.
Judge orders seizure of homes belonging to Montreal billionaire accused of sex abuse
A Quebec Superior Court judge has ordered the seizure of two Montreal-area residences belonging to billionaire Robert Miller, at the request of four women who have filed civil lawsuits alleging he sexually abused them as minors.
opinion
opinion Tom Mulcair: Is Justin Trudeau just playing out the clock?
Former NDP leader Tom Mulcair says Canada is facing critical issues that need an active, engaged federal government right now; but Prime Minister Trudeau seems to be running out the clock before the next election.
Western embassies in Kyiv shut due to Russian air attack threat after Biden policy shift
The U.S. and some other western embassies in Kyiv said that they would stay closed Wednesday for security reasons, with the American delegation saying it had received a warning of a potentially significant Russian air attack on the Ukrainian capital.
Two undersea cables in Baltic Sea disrupted, sparking warnings of possible 'hybrid warfare'
Two undersea internet cables in the Baltic Sea have been suddenly disrupted, according to local telecommunications companies, amid fresh warnings of possible Russian interference with global undersea infrastructure.
'I'm just tickled pink': Two childhood friends from New Brunswick named Rhodes Scholars
Two young women from New Brunswick have won one of the most prestigious and sought-after academic honours in the world.
Canada Post strike could hurt charity donations during holiday season
Charities and non-profits are having to pivot after nearly 55,000 workers represented by the Canadian Union of Postal Workers walked off the job Friday. The strike has halted mail from going out and charities are concerned it may stop donations from coming in.
Rogers Sports and Media cuts a 'few dozen' jobs in its audio business
Rogers Sports and Media has cut what it says are a 'few dozen' jobs in its audio business.
Shopping Trends
The Shopping Trends team is independent of the journalists at CTV News. We may earn a commission when you use our links to shop. Read about us.
Montreal
-
The use of French is declining in shops, but young people are indifferent to it: OQLF
The use of French as a greeting and service language in Quebec businesses is declining across the province, but particularly in the Montreal and Gatineau regions, a situation that is leaving more and more Quebecers indifferent, especially among young people.
-
Judge orders seizure of homes belonging to Montreal billionaire accused of sex abuse
A Quebec Superior Court judge has ordered the seizure of two Montreal-area residences belonging to billionaire Robert Miller, at the request of four women who have filed civil lawsuits alleging he sexually abused them as minors.
-
A 'lot of ground' remains between Canada Post, workers as strike talks progress
Canada Post and the postal workers union found slivers of consensus Tuesday amid talks with a special mediator, but 'a lot of ground' remains between them on the key concerns as a countrywide strike entered its fifth day.
Ottawa
-
Here's where 39 photo radar cameras will be installed in Ottawa over the next 14 months
Thirty-nine new photo radar cameras will be installed to keep an eye on Ottawa roads over the next 14 months, including on roads in the rural villages of Dunrobin, Manotick, Richmond and Vars.
-
Ottawa restaurant claims spot on Canada's top 100 list
A cozy dining spot in Ottawa's Little Italy has cracked OpenTable's top 100 restaurants in Canada for 2024.
-
Heavy rain expected in Ottawa tonight and on Thursday
The stretch of mild weather continues in Ottawa today, but heavy rain is expected on Thursday and there is a risk of flurries heading into the weekend.
Northern Ontario
-
Swiftie's friendship bracelet beads confiscated at Calgary airport
A Canadian Taylor Swift fan has some 'Bad Blood' with the Calgary International Airport after security staff confiscated hundreds of dollars worth of beads she was going to use to make friendship bracelets.
-
Sudbury pharmacy tech creates a better way to label prescriptions
Avalon Lupini, who has been a pharmacy technician in Sudbury for 17 years, has come up with an innovative solution to a common problem.
-
Can't you smell that smell? Cannabis odour leads to major drug bust in Espanola, Ont.
The smell of pot from a vehicle during a RIDE check in Espanola led police to find $41,200 in cannabis, along with 140 gummies and 50 vape pens.
Kitchener
-
Mother says spreading kindness is helping her heal after son’s tragic death
The mother of a man who was fatally shot in Cambridge is marking the painful anniversary of his death by giving to others.
-
'Doors shaking from bombing': Ukrainian refugee living in Kitchener looks back at 1,000 days of Ukraine-Russia war
A Ukrainian, now living in Kitchener, describes what life is like back home and what she's doing to help her fellow refugees.
-
When will we see the first snow of the season?
The first snowfall of the season could come this week – but don’t worry, it won’t be sticking around.
London
-
Advisory in effect as thick fog blankets most of southern Ontario
Environment Canada has issued a fog advisory, warning that dense fog has developed with near zero visibility in some areas.
-
Dozens of Londoners tell city council their priorities ahead of municipal budget deliberations
On Tuesday, 45 Londoners took part in a public participation meeting to voice their priorities for municipal spending amid another anticipated property tax hike.
-
Service Depot locations that provide food, water, and hygiene to Londoners in encampments to close mid-winter
The future provision of basic needs to Londoners living in homeless encampments was thrown into doubt after a marathon debate by council’s Strategic Priorities and Policy Committee (SPPC).
Windsor
-
OPP on scene of two separate crashes in Essex County
OPP are advising drivers to slow down and be cautious of reduced visibility due to fog.
-
Buses cancelled in Windsor-Essex Wednesday morning
All school board provided bus transportation has been cancelled for City of Windsor and Area B. Afternoon transpiration will be operational.
-
Warrant issued for murder suspect in death of missing Windsor man
An arrest warrant has been issued by Windsor police for a 30-year-old woman wanted related to the death of a man who went missing earlier this year.
Barrie
-
Police standoff in north end Barrie plaza ends after 14 hours
Police in Barrie say a man involved in a situation in the city’s north end that resulted in evacuations surrendered to officers roughly 14 hours after barricading himself inside a camper.
-
Two teens arrested after weapon-related investigation at Caledon high school
Caledon OPP says officers responded to a weapon-related incident around 1 p.m. involving two youths at Robert F. Hall Catholic Secondary School.
-
Young 'high miler' charged with speeding 188km/h on Hwy 400
A young driver may be taking public transit for the next month after police charged him with stunt driving along Highway 400.
Winnipeg
-
Schools closed; buses cancelled amid snowy weather in Manitoba
A blast of winter weather has caused school closures and bus cancellations around Manitoba.
-
Storm bringing heavy snow, strong winds to Manitoba
Stormy weather and strong winds have touched down in western Manitoba, with some areas expected to receive up to 50 centimetres (cm) of snow.
-
Police say threat resolved after report of man with knife at University of Manitoba
An incident involving reports of a man armed with a knife at the University of Manitoba Fort Garry Campus has been resolved according to Winnipeg police.
Atlantic
-
Cape Breton man's disappearance now ruled a homicide
Police in Cape Breton are now treating the disappearance of Kenneth “Justin” MacDonald as a homicide.
-
A 'lot of ground' remains between Canada Post, workers as strike talks progress
Canada Post and the postal workers union found slivers of consensus Tuesday amid talks with a special mediator, but 'a lot of ground' remains between them on the key concerns as a countrywide strike entered its fifth day.
-
Canada Post strike could hurt charity donations during holiday season
Charities and non-profits are having to pivot after nearly 55,000 workers represented by the Canadian Union of Postal Workers walked off the job Friday. The strike has halted mail from going out and charities are concerned it may stop donations from coming in.
N.L.
-
Newfoundland wind-to-hydrogen company eyes data centre as international market lags
A company hoping to build a multi-billion-dollar wind-to-hydrogen project in western Newfoundland is eyeing other options as Canada's plans to supply Europe with green energy have not yet materialized.
-
Seniors face unique hurdles in finding love. These Canadians want to help.
The four women sipping tea around an antique wooden table in rural Newfoundland said they weren't looking for much in a mate: kindness, humour, a good sense of fun and, ideally, a full set of teeth.
-
English soccer game did not deliver such a big bounce for N.L. after all: province
Newfoundland and Labrador's return on investment for sponsoring a professional English soccer team was not quite as rosy as previously claimed.
Edmonton
-
Scammers have stolen more than $37M in Edmonton this year. Here's how
From text messages to phone calls and in-person interactions, scam artists are trying to con you out of your money.
-
Oilers end road trip with win over Senators
After a shutout loss the night before, the Edmonton Oilers bounced back on Tuesday with a convincing 5-2 victory over the host Ottawa Senators.
-
Developer makes plea to Alberta government to reconsider plan to demolish old museum
An Edmonton property developer known for reimaging old buildings says it's bewildered the Alberta government has moved ahead with a plan to tear down the former provincial museum.
Calgary
-
Calgary doctor charged with sexual assault of multiple patients
A Calgary doctor is facing charges after allegedly sexually assaulting four patients between 2016 and 2020. Police say all four victims came forward independently in 2023 to report their alleged assaults.
-
Calgary police, fire make pitches to city council during mid-cycle budget talks
The Calgary Police Commission is proposing to use money earmarked for community crisis and mental-health groups to fund a new firearms range, unless the city offers up more in its budget.
-
Swiftie's friendship bracelet beads confiscated at Calgary airport
A Canadian Taylor Swift fan has some 'Bad Blood' with the Calgary International Airport after security staff confiscated hundreds of dollars worth of beads she was going to use to make friendship bracelets.
Regina
-
Sask. experiences first snowfall of the winter season, conditions affecting travellers
Since Monday night, snow has been falling in Saskatchewan in many areas throughout the province. This has caused chaos both on the roads for drivers and those passengers travelling by air.
-
Indigenous elders, archaeologists, scholars come together to explore significant sites
A group of Indigenous elders, archaeologists and scholars have come together to explore historically significant sites pertaining to Indigenous ancestry.
-
Provincial emergency alert test scheduled for Wednesday
Those in Saskatchewan may get an alert on their cell phones, TV, and radio Wednesday afternoon as part of a provincial emergency alert test.
Saskatoon
-
Saskatoon medical aesthetics business closes, leaving clients out thousands
Clients of a medical aesthetics business in Saskatoon are left waiting for any indication their pre-bought services will be fulfilled after the business closed permanently.
-
'Nowhere to go': Saskatoon community groups rise to offer warm shelter as temperatures plummet
As Saskatoon buckles down for winter, the staff at Prairie Harm Reduction gears up for the influx of people through their doors.
-
Saskatoon clearing priority streets after first major snowfall
Saskatoon residents woke to find the city under a blanket of snow on Tuesday, with around 10 centimetres falling overnight and more on the way.
Vancouver
-
Incoming ‘bomb cyclone’ could bring coastal flooding
Flooding in coastal areas could occur across the Lower Mainland on Wednesday, as the incoming bomb cyclone looks set to bring with it higher than usual tides.
-
All NDP MLAs receive a new title, and all but one get a raise
Premier David Eby’s new cabinet is a big one. Despite winning ten fewer seats than former premier John Horgan, he has three more ministers than the previous leader.
-
Bomb cyclone batters B.C. with hurricane-force winds, cutting roads and power
Hurricane-force winds of up to 159 km/h have slammed into parts of the British Columbia coast as a massive storm swirling off Vancouver Island severed highways and cut power to about 225,000 people.
Vancouver Island
-
Bomb cyclone batters B.C. with hurricane-force winds, cutting roads and power
Hurricane-force winds of up to 159 km/h have slammed into parts of the British Columbia coast as a massive storm swirling off Vancouver Island severed highways and cut power to about 225,000 people.
-
Strong winds, downed trees force closure of Vancouver Island highway
An almost 40 kilometre stretch of Highway 4 on Vancouver Island was closed Tuesday evening due to the impacts of a storm that forecasted to batter the South Coast.
-
BC Ferries cancels sailings on major routes due to incoming storm
BC Ferries has cancelled Tuesday evening's sailings between the Lower Mainland and Vancouver Island in anticipation of an incoming storm.
