McGuinty blames Ottawa for Electro-Motive closing
Published Monday, February 6, 2012 11:31PM EST
OAKVILLE, Ont. - Ottawa could have prevented the loss of hundreds of jobs at an Ontario locomotive plant if it had acted to modernize Canada's "outdated" foreign investment laws, Premier Dalton McGuinty said Monday.
U.S.-based Caterpillar, which is planning to close the Electro-Motive plant, never had any "sincere interest" in staying in London after it bought the factory, he said in a speech to the Oakville Chamber of Commerce.
"Eighteen months ago, when Caterpillar bought that plant, they had to get the approval of the federal government under an outdated law called the Investment Canada Act," McGuinty said.
"I believe there's something fundamentally wrong with a federal law when it allows a Canadian plant to be bought and stripped clean in short order, throwing Canadian families out of work."
The Harper government acknowledged the need for change a long time ago, "but they haven't done anything about it," he added.
The premier struck a more conciliatory tone after the speech, insisting he's not trying to lay blame. Rather, Harper should draw a lesson from the experience and review the act.
"I think it's really time that we did that and see if there is a better assessment that we can bring to potential investors to determine their sincerity of their commitment in that business in that community," he said.
However, the federal government said a month ago that the takeover was never looked at by Investment Canada because it fell under the $300-million threshold.
A spokeswoman for the Prime Minister's Office said the government sympathizes with the workers, but there was nothing Ottawa could do.
"This issue fell entirely within the powers of the McGuinty government, there was no ability for the federal government to intervene," spokeswoman Sara MacIntyre wrote in an email.
That's not true, McGuinty said. What happened at Electro-Motive wasn't a labour relations issue, "and we shouldn't pretend otherwise."
The 450 employees had been asked to take a 50 per cent pay cut to help keep the plant open. The CAW union members rejected the proposal, prompting the company to lock them out Jan. 1.
Caterpillar subsidiary (NYSE:CAT) Progress Rail Services said the cost structure at the London plant was unsustainable, even though Caterpillar last week reported a 58 per cent increase in its quarterly earnings with a record profit of nearly $5 billion.
It bought Electro-Motive for US$820 million in cash from Berkshire Partners LLC and Greenbriar Equity Group LLC in 2010.
"This company, we have learned, had no sincere interest in a long-term presence in that community," McGuinty said.
"In 21 years (of public service), I have never heard of a business -- domestic or international -- that said to an employee group, 'We're going to cut your wages in half, this is a take-it-or-leave-it offer'," he added.
"That's a 'We're getting out of town' kind of an offer to me."
But McGuinty could have done more to help workers before the axe fell on Electro-Motive, said Essex New Democrat Taras Natyshak. And pointing the finger at Ottawa after the fact comes as cold comfort to those who are losing their jobs.
"Sounds like a buck-pass to me," he said.
The Progressive Conservatives insist high hydro rates and increased business taxes under a Liberal government are driving many companies out of Ontario.
"It shows you something's wrong in the province, that we've made Ontario a much more expensive jurisdiction," said Opposition Leader Tim Hudak.
"And who pays the price? People looking for jobs who literally had jobs. We just need a different approach when it comes to the economy."
However, the Liberals counter that they've made Ontario more competitive than most U.S. states by cutting the corporate tax rate to 11.5 per cent.