Law Society of Ontario's actions against applicants accused of cheating on bar exam violated 'procedural fairness,' court rules
![Osgoode Hall Osgoode Hall is seen in Toronto on Wednesday, Sept. 25, 2019. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Colin Perkel](/content/dam/cp24/en/images/2022/3/6/osgoode-hall-1-5807656-1646583892670.jpg)
The Law Society of Ontario violated “procedural fairness” with some of the “punitive” measures it imposed on applicants accused of cheating on the bar exam two years ago.
The LSO previously voided the exam results of more than 100 candidates who wrote the November 2021 test after the law society said it had come to light that exam materials had been improperly accessed. The LSO accused the candidates of engaging in “prohibited actions” and also voided their registration in the licensing process while preventing them from re-applying for one year.
- Download our app to get local alerts on your device
- Get the latest local updates right to your inbox
While the decision to void the test results was warranted, the other measures “substantially impacted the applicants to the point of being punitive,” read a divisional court decision released last week.
“It was a violation of procedural fairness to impose that level of consequence without holding a hearing or reaching a determination that the applicants had engaged in intentional misconduct,” the decision read.
“On the issue of remedy, we quash the LSO’s decisions other than the voiding of exam results and remit these matters to the LSO to determine next steps in accordance with these reasons.”
The LSO began conducting the exams online in the spring of 2020 as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. After it was discovered that test materials were being leaked, in-person exams resumed last year.
In the summer of 2022, the LSO launched a lawsuit against NCA Exam Guru, which provides bar exam test preparation. The company’s director, Mississauga resident Aamer Chaudhry, is also named in the suit. The LSO alleges that the company has “been obtaining and providing to those enrolled in its preparation courses documents containing questions from the licensing examinations.”
The LSO also accused the company of providing the answers to those questions, allowing clients to cheat on licensing examinations.
The decision notes that the applicants involved have “suffered a permanent stain on their reputation.”
“It has been almost two years since they wrote their exams. Their professional lives have been in limbo and they have undoubtedly suffered personally as a result,” the decision read.
It noted that the actions of the LSO could hurt candidates in terms of future employment prospects.
“The LSO highlighted that it would share the decision with legal regulators across Canada. Similarly, the finding of a regulatory sanction could prevent the Applicants from successfully applying to a different regulated profession where this would need to be disclosed,” the decision stated.
“A law firm interested in hiring an Applicant could ask questions that would elicit this history and then be dissuaded from hiring the lawyer or paralegal.”
The decision notes that while the LSO “faced an administrative challenge in this case,” that “cannot override the Applicants’ fundamental right to procedural fairness.”
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.6977053.1721909931!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.jpg)
'Sick to my stomach': People grieve Jasper National Park by sharing favourite photos
As an out-of-control wildfire roared through Alberta’s famed Jasper National Park and its townsite late Wednesday, many are fearing the worst as officials warned of 'significant loss' within the area.
DEVELOPING Jasper wildfire burns buildings, while poor air quality forces some fire crews out
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau announced on social media that Ottawa has approved Alberta's request for federal assistance after a fast-moving wildfire hit Jasper National Park and its townsite late Wednesday.
Canadian women's soccer team staffer given suspended prison sentence over drone incident, prosecutor says
A Canada women's soccer team staffer has been given an eight-month suspended prison sentence after flying a drone to film the closed-door training session of the New Zealand team on Monday, the prosecutor's office said in a statement.
Sale of envoy's NYC condo 'expected to exceed' $9M: government
The current official residence for Canada's representative in New York City is 'being readied for sale,' according to a spokesperson from Global Affairs Canada.
'I'm so broke': Two Toronto women speak out after losing $76,000 in romance scam
Two women from the Toronto area are speaking out after losing thousands of dollars to a romance scam, including a single mother who lost $62,000.
Barrie-Innisfil MPP 'blacked-out' and crashed car into window of child care centre
Staff at a Barrie child care centre say they are frustrated by what they call a local MPP's inadequate response after a car crashed through a window in one of the toddler rooms.
Loblaw, George Weston to settle class action over bread price-fixing for $500 million
Loblaw Cos. Ltd. and its parent company George Weston Ltd. say they have agreed to pay $500-million to settle a class-action lawsuit regarding their involvement in an alleged bread price-fixing scheme.
EXCLUSIVE One address, 76 foreign currency dealers: Inside Canada's money service business 'clusters'
An IJF and CTV News investigation has found dozens of cases across Canada where multiple money services businesses (MSBs) are incorporated at the same address, sometimes without the knowledge or consent of the location's actual occupant. One money laundering expert calls it an 'abuse of the system.'
An unwelcome attendee has joined the Paris Olympic Games: COVID-19
After a handful of Australian water polo players tested positive for COVID-19 this week, questions have emerged around how the spread of the disease will be mitigated at the Summer Olympic Games in Paris.