GTA police service loses bid to keep workplace investigation reports redacted
A Toronto-area police service's attempt to shield information outlined in two workplace investigations has been dismissed by the courts.
In Ontario Superior Court of Justice documents released last week, the Durham Regional Police Service (DRPS) sought to hide the full unredacted reports from being disclosed, arguing they were privileged and confidential.
- Download our app to get local alerts on your device
- Get the latest local updates right to your inbox
The application was bourne out of an investigation into the service launched in 2019 by the Ontario Civilian Police Commission into allegations of misconduct within the workplace.
As part of the 2019 workplace investigation, the commission requested to receive two reports authored by an outside lawyer.
It is these reports that Durham police first opposed handing over, according to the document. However, at an October hearing, lawyers for DRPS agreed to provide the reports to the commission "on the condition that [they] are not further disclosed, disseminated, or made publicly available due to confidentiality concerns." They argued that the redactions were done to "protect the personal health information of our members," the decision reads.
Lawyers for the commission rejected that submission and argued that transparency was important to protect employees from "harassment and a poisoned work environment," the filing states.
After hearing the parties' submissions the presiding judge, Justice Julia Shin Doi, ruled in favour of the commission, ordering Durham police to hand over the reports without restriction.
“There should be no restrictions attached to the production of either [report],” Shin Doi wrote in her decision, stating she had no concerns over a possible breach of confidentiality.
“There is also a greater public interest and benefit in disclosure without restriction to protect the employees from harassment and a toxic workplace, as advocated by the Association,” the judge continued
When reached for comment, a spokesperson for DRPS described the motion as “one aspect related to the overall OCPC investigation that has been ongoing for many years.”
Once the matter has concluded, the service said it will provide comment.
The investigation in which the workplace reports were ordered also saw Deputy Chief Dean Bertrim charged with deceit under the Police Services Act (PSA) by the OCPC in 2023.
On Wednesday, Durham police confirmed to CTV News Toronto that the reports do not concern Bertrim. The allegation of deceit faced by Bertrim under the PSA has yet to be tested under separate disciplinary tribunal proceedings.
In a Notice of Particulars, the commission alleged Bertrim provided false testimony as part of a motion to dismiss professional disciplinary charges against two officers in 2018. A year earlier, Bertrim had asked a professional standards investigator to conduct a review of the two officers’ conduct and produce documentation prior to serving them with notice of a hearing, according to OCPC. It is alleged, however, that the investigator never provided Bertrim with the report – because Bertrim never requested it. While testifying to the matter in 2018, Bertrim swore the report had been reviewed by now-retired chief Paul Martin during an August meeting, as is required under the police disciplinary process.
The disciplinary process against the two officers was stayed in June 2018 on the basis that Martin had not been provided with a written report, according to the notice.
Correction
CORRECTION: A prior version of this article stated that the two reports were requested as part of the ongoing disciplinary proceedings against Deputy Chief Dean Bertrim, when they were in fact requested as part of the OCPC investigation launched in 2019. CTV News has amended the error. Durham police have since confirmed that the reports in the April decision do not concern the proceedings against Deputy Chief Dean Bertrim, which have yet to be tested in a separate disciplinary tribunal matter.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Infant dies in ATV crash, N.S. RCMP says alcohol may be a factor
An infant has died and three others, including another child, were taken to hospital following an ATV crash in Forties, N.S., on Monday.
Canadians are eyeing moves to these cities for more affordable housing
Faced with elevated housing prices, half of Canadians in the country's largest cities are considering moving to places with more affordable housing.
Charges against world's top golfer Scottie Scheffler dropped after arrest outside PGA Championship
Criminal charges against Scottie Scheffler have been dismissed, ending a legal saga that began with images of the world’s top male golfer being arrested and handcuffed in Louisville during the PGA Championship.
'Do not drive': Nissan warns Canadian drivers of explosion risk impacting 48,000 vehicles
Car manufacturer Nissan has issued a do-not-drive warning for some older vehicles equipped with Takata airbag inflators, due to the risk of explosion during a crash.
'Scandals and secrets': On board the world's most exclusive private residential ship
It’s a floating city exclusively home to the 1 per cent, a playground for multimillionaires and billionaires that circumnavigates the world's oceans.
Tessa Virtue reveals she's expecting her first child. Here's what Canadians had to say
Canadian figure-skating icon Tessa Virtue is expecting her first child, she revealed via social media Tuesday.
How Trump's hush money trial verdict could affect the 2024 election
Here is how three potential outcomes from the jury room ─ a guilty verdict, an acquittal or a hung jury ─ could affect the presidential campaign.
'Are you driving?' U.S. man with suspended licence shows up on court Zoom call while behind the wheel
A Michigan man with a suspended driver's licence didn't appear to have thought through a recent court appearance made on video, joining the Zoom call while driving.
An Iceland volcano starts erupting again, spewing lava into the sky
A volcano in southwestern Iceland erupted Wednesday for the fifth time since December, spewing red streams of lava in the latest display of nature’s power and triggering the evacuation of the popular Blue Lagoon geothermal spa.