Final arguments presented to jury in Peter Nygard's sex assault trial
Two different portraits of disgraced mogul Peter Nygard were painted during closing arguments of his ongoing Toronto sex assault trial Tuesday — one, by his defence lawyers, of a dedicated businessman committed to his company, and another, by prosecutors, of a man who used his power and wealth to allegedly force women into nonconsensual sexual encounters, berating them if they opposed.
Nygard, now 82, was wheeled into a downtown courtroom Tuesday wearing a black suit, his long grey hair tied back into a low bun, and a pair of black-rimmed glasses for the final days of proceedings. He’s pleaded not guilty to five counts of sexual assault and one count of forcible confinement in alleged incidents ranging from the 1980s to mid-2000s.
- Download our app to get local alerts on your device
- Get the latest local updates right to your inbox
Last month, five women, whose identities are protected by a court-ordered publication ban, told the court that the businessman sexually assaulted them in the top-floor suite of his Toronto headquarters.
THE DEFENCE
Much of the case against disgraced fashion mogul Peter Nygard has been built upon "revisionist history," his defence lawyer argued, opening the closing arguments Tuesday morning.
“To describe Peter Nygard as an evil predator, a Jekyll and Hyde type of personality, who through wealth and power, lured women and forced them to comply with his sexual demands is neither fair nor accurate,” Brian Greenspan said.
“His life was neither hidden nor secreted, nor were his workspaces, nor were his homes, nor were his private quarters – his passion for his work was open and transparent, his lifestyle was open and transparent.”
In his closing submission to the 12-person jury, Greenspan worked to paint a starkly different portrait than what five women testified to weeks earlier, instead describing a well-respected businessman who cared deeply for his employees and company. Last month, the women, whose identities are protected by a court-ordered publication ban, told the court that the businessman sexually assaulted them in the top-floor suite of his Toronto headquarters.
In the defence’s submission, Greenspan suggested that the complainants' memories could no longer be relied upon as sufficient evidence given the decades that have passed since the alleged offences. In turn, he argued that the Crown's case was built off of "contradictions and innuendo."
At one point, he suggested that much of what has been claimed about Nygard has veered into "revisionist history."
Nygard himself has struggled with memory issues, Greenspan underlined. As the defendant, Nygard was not required to prove anything, call forth witnesses, nor provide evidence, he said.
By taking the stand, Greenspan argued Nygard displayed a level of cooperativeness.
“When someone is accused of historical offences from decades ago, probing their memory often becomes the only defence,” Greenspan said.
“He spent almost five days in the witness box. He did his best to be candid, cooperative, and truthful.”
Moving through the counts, Greenspan worked to point out alleged inconsistencies in the complainants' testimonies, landing on the conclusion that prosecution, using these accounts, had failed in its efforts to prove Nygard's innocence.
"Peter Nygard must be acquitted because the prosecution has utterly failed to establish his guilt beyond a reasonable doubt," Greenspan stated.
Once the prosecution replies and submits its own closing argument on Tuesday afternoon, Nygard and his lawyers will have no opportunity to respond, Greenspan told the jurors.
“We have no right to reply, no right to take issue despite the fact we might have been totally able to respond,” he said. “I simply ask that you do not conclude that we would not be able to answer."
THE CROWN
Attorney Ana Serban opened the Crown’s closing submission by telling the jurors that if they believed the testimonies given by the women, they “should have no difficulty finding Peter Nygard guilty of sexual assault.”
“Their accounts are not carbon copies of each other, but what they describe is the same space and the same behavior by Mr. Nygard,” Serban said.
“It defies coincidence,” she said.
Serban rejected the notion that the complainants’ testimonies were unreliable, arguing the number of purported inconsistencies within their accounts were no more than that of Nygard’s.
She also pointed to similarities between the women’s accounts – at least two of the women testified that they were physically pinned down in similar fashions during the alleged assaults, and that, in the absence of consent, that Nygard berated them.
‘How else do these women know about this behaviour if they haven’t witnessed it from Mr. Nygard?” Serban asked the jury.
Pushing back against the claim that Nygard had done his best to be candid during the proceedings, Serban argued that, during the former businessman’s testimony, he was not focused on telling the truth.
“He wasn't focused on telling the truth, he wanted to figure out the stretch,” she said, adding that, at one point, Nygard accused the prosecutors of trying to “trap him.”
Serban alleged her own inconsistencies between an interview Nygard voluntarily participated in with police in 2021 and his court testimony, including varying accounts of the placement of the locks in his top-floor suite.
Ultimately, Serban worked to convince the jurors that the complainants were in fact reliable enough to be believed.
“And if you believe these women, you should have no trouble finding Peter Nygard guilty,” she said.
The jury is set to begin deliberations on Wednesday.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Canadian family stuck in Lebanon anxiously awaits flight options amid Israeli strikes
A Canadian man who is trapped in Lebanon with his family says they are anxiously waiting for seats on a flight out of the country, as a barrage of Israeli airstrikes continues.
Yazidi woman captured by ISIS rescued in Gaza after more than a decade in captivity
A 21-year-old Yazidi woman has been rescued from Gaza where she had been held captive by Hamas for years after being trafficked by ISIS.
Scientists looked at images from space to see how fast Antarctica is turning green. Here's what they found
Parts of icy Antarctica are turning green with plant life at an alarming rate as the region is gripped by extreme heat events, according to new research, sparking concerns about the changing landscape on this vast continent.
DEVELOPING 2 dead after fire rips through historic building in Old Montreal
At least two people are dead and others are injured after a fire ripped through a century-old building near Montreal's City Hall, sources told Noovo Info.
Suspect in shooting of Toronto cop was out on bail
A 21-year-old man who was charged with attempted murder in the shooting of a Toronto police officer this week was out on bail at the time of the alleged offence, court documents obtained by CTV News Toronto show.
A 6-year-old girl was kidnapped in Arkansas in 1995. Almost 30 years later, a suspect was identified
Nearly 30 years after a six-year-old girl disappeared in Western Arkansas, authorities have identified a suspect in her abduction through DNA evidence.
Dolphins 'smile' at each other when they play and to avoid misunderstanding, study finds
For humans, flashing a smile is an easy way to avoid misunderstanding. And, according to a new study, bottlenose dolphins may use a similar tactic while playing with each other.
Haitian gang kills at least 70 people, including 3 infants, UN says
Armed men belonging to the Gran Grif gang killed at least 70 people, including three infants, as they swept through a Haitian town shooting automatic rifles at residents, a spokesperson for the United Nations' Human Rights Office said on Friday.
Pit bulls in B.C. pet mauling tested positive for meth, cocaine, says city
Three pit bulls involved in a deadly attack on another dog last month in Kamloops, B.C., tested positive for methamphetamine and cocaine, and the city is going to court to have them put down.