Trial of Toronto driver accused in fatal collision in jeopardy over missing piece of paper
A Toronto family is in shock after learning that one lost sheet of paper in a court proceeding could result in the case against a dump truck driver accused of fatally striking their loved one getting thrown out.
Shona Siddiqui says it’s astonishing that her family could go through three years of legal proceedings since her brother Asim Siddiqui was killed in 2019, only to have the case possibly sidelined by what sounds like an arcane rule.
“This was the most devastating moment of my life. He was my youngest sibling, my only brother, the spark of my family,” Siddqui said.
“And now if there’s a technicality that says you’re not responsible for killing someone on the street and not even accountable for it because we lost something, that’s it,” she said.
Shona Siddiqui’s husband, Ray Lacina, said he couldn’t believe that in 2022 all cases don’t have some kind of digital backup.
“Why is this not electronic at this point?” asked Shona Siddiqui’s husband, Ray Lacina.
Asim Siddiqui, 40, was run down in January 2019 by a dump truck on Lawrence Avenue West and Marlee Avenue. He was a consultant at a bank branch in North York. At the time, police officers said the vehicle failed to remain at the scene.
Toronto police at the scene of a fatal crash involving a pedestrian on Lawrence Avenue on January 16, 2019.
Nothing could bring him back, but his family had hopes for a hearing at Provincial Offences court, where driver Nicolas Brown had pled guilty to the non-criminal Highway Traffic Act offense of failure to yield to a pedestrian.
But the hearing Tuesday was in disarray, with the sworn information, which outlines the charge, missing. Court staff said they had searched for it but in vain. A photocopy provided by one of the lawyers was not good enough.
Brown’s lawyer, Neil Searles, argued that as a result, “This court has lost jurisdiction over the matter."
The judge didn’t rule on that point, opting to give the court staff time to find the missing document. The case will next be heard on March 2.
Lawyer Ari Goldkind, who is not connected to the case, says while other courts have upgraded to electronic systems, the Provincial Offenses court, which is run by the City of Toronto, is often stuck in paper.
“What we’re talking about is the sworn information. That’s the thing that allows a judge to act on something in court,” Goldkind said.
Usually it deals with minor matters, but in this case, a life was lost, he said.
“While these errors often happen, I can’t remember that last time it happened in a case of this significance. Our system is a Luddite of a system and many lawyers are begging for it to be moved into the 20th century,” he said.
The City of Toronto told CTV News Toronto in a statement that it’s rare to lose documents, and when that happens, the court staff will conduct a thorough search.
“The charges were not dismissed. Court Services staff will notify the defendants legal counsel and the prosecutor when the original is located by January 31, 2022,” the city said in a statement.
It said the court’s case management system and records are under the authority of the Ontario Court of Justice. In 2020, the city received approval from the Ontario Court of Justice for maintaining a digital copy of new court charges to support remote processes, and the city implemented that in September.
However, older cases proceed by older rules, the statement said.
Meanwhile, other courts such as the Ontario Superior Court have a digital system.
Toronto has a long way to go before deaths on the road are taken seriously, said Jess Spieker of Friends and Families for Safe Streets.
She said there have been no criminal charges in the case, another charge of careless driving was stayed after the plea, and by going down a route through the POA court exposed victims’ families to the risk of justice being denied.
“It’s wild that our systems are so outdated and antiquated,” she said. “The courts need proper budgeting and proper reasoning to get things going.”
She pointed to the need for Bill 54, which would provide a license suspension, mandatory driver re-training, mandatory community service, and compulsory attendance at traffic court to hear a victim impact statement.
The bill has recently passed a second reading in Ontario’s legislature.
Shona Siddiqui said she hopes the case gets back on track, and said she hopes that she will be able to read her victim impact statement in open court, with Brown listening.
“There’s a lot we have lost. There’s a deep darkness in our lives that has impacted all of us differently,” she said.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
DEVELOPING Live updates as Stormy Daniels testifies at Trump hush money trial
Adult film star Stormy Daniels will take the stand a second time Thursday as former U.S. president Donald Trump’s hush money case continues in Manhattan. Follow live updates here.
NEW Why these immigrants to Canada say they're thinking about leaving, or have already moved on
For some immigrants, their dreams of permanently settling in Canada have taken an unexpected twist.
Here are the ultraprocessed foods you most need to avoid, according to a 30-year study
Studies have shown that ultraprocessed foods can have a detrimental impact on health. But 30 years of research show they don’t all have the same impact.
NEW Capital gains tax change 'shortsighted' and 'sows division' business groups tell Freeland
Forging ahead with increasing Canada's capital gains inclusion rate 'sows division,' and is a 'shortsighted' way to improve the deficit, business groups are warning Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland.
Ontario man frustrated after $3,500 paving job leaves driveway in shambles
An Ontario man considering having his driveway paved received a quote from a company for $7,000, but then, another paver in the neighbourhood knocked on his door and offered half that rate.
Defence attacks Stormy Daniels' credibility as she returns to the stand in Trump's hush money trial
Stormy Daniels will return to the witness stand Thursday in Donald Trump's hush money trial as the defence tries to undermine the credibility of the porn actor's salacious testimony about their alleged sexual encounter and the money she was paid to keep quiet.
With contactless screening tech, this Toronto startup hopes to catch breast cancer early — and save lives
Amid evidence of rising breast cancer rates among young women in Canada, one Toronto startup is offering a contactless and radiation-free device that can help doctors identify suspicious changes in breast tissue. The company, Linda Lifetech, says this can lead to earlier detection of breast cancer.
Tornadoes tear through southeastern U.S. as storms leave 3 dead
Forecasters warned a wave of dangerous storms in the U.S. could wash over parts of the South early Thursday, a day after severe weather with damaging tornadoes and large hail killed at least three people in the region.
Police handcuff man trying to enter Drake's Toronto mansion
Toronto police say a man was taken into custody outside Drake's Bridle Path mansion Wednesday afternoon after he tried to gain access to the residence.