Stacy Clarke appeals 'excessive' and 'harsh' demotion for role in officer cheating scandal
A high-ranking Toronto police officer who admitted to helping several members of the service cheat on promotional exams is appealing her demotion, arguing that she was “villainized” for conduct which was “rampant” throughout the organization.
In August, Stacy Clarke was handed a 24-month demotion from the rank of superintendent to inspector after pleading guilty to seven professional misconduct charges.
She had previously admitted that she’d helped six Black constables who she had been mentoring gain an unfair advantage on promotional exams back in 2021.
But her lawyers argued that she took those actions in an attempt to address “overt and systemic anti-Black racism” within the TPS and help diversify its ranks.
The notice of appeal submitted on Clarke’s behalf on Sept. 26 calls the decision to demote Clarke without automatically returning her to her former rank at the conclusion of the penalty “excessive, harsh, unwarranted and disproportionate.”
“The hearing officer failed to give sufficient weight to the appellant’s testimony on the culture within the Toronto Police Service, the frequency of similar misconduct, and its impact on her actions,” the appeal states.
“Instead, the hearing officer villainized the appellant for conduct that was rampant within the organization. In so doing, the hearing officer failed to properly weigh the important mitigating factor that, in part, explained the offending conduct.”
Clarke was the first Black officer to hold the rank of superintendent in Toronto police history.
In the appeal, lawyers for Clarke argue that while the hearing officer “acknowledged overt and systemic anti-Black racism and the appellant’s lived experience of racism,” they did not give “sufficient weight” to those factors.
The lawyers also said that the hearing officer failed to give sufficient weight to the “collateral consequence to marginalized communities” should Clarke not be automatically reinstated to her history-making rank.
“The hearing officer’s finding that the public interest assessment was aggravating was not supported by the evidence. Rather, the public interest assessment is mitigating, especially given the hearing officer’s acceptance of that evidence,” the appeal states.
In her decision in August, hearing officer Robin McElary-Downer said that she had “no doubt” Clarke is “deeply remorseful” and that the allegations against her arose “from a unique set of circumstances,” specifically her “lived experiences as a visible minority member of the Toronto police.”
McElary-Downer, however, found that Clark’s misconduct ultimately fell “far below the standard expected of a police officer.”
“While the underlying reasons for her misconduct help make it seem less nefarious, [Clarke] single handedly brought down these officers who showed promise as future leaders in the Toronto Police Service,” McElary-Downersaid at the time.
Clarke’s appeal will be considered by the Ontario Civilian Police Commission. A date has not yet been set for that hearing.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
BREAKING Cuba's power grid fails, plunging country into darkness
Cuba's national electrical grid shut down on Friday after one of the island's major power plants failed, Cuba's energy ministry said, plunging the entire country into a blackout.
Cabinet minister who is quitting voices confidence in Trudeau
One of four Canadian cabinet members who are stepping down said on Friday that he has confidence in Liberal Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, and he played down polls predicting the Liberals will badly lose in the next election.
SaskPower receives largest workplace fine in province's history for 2020 deaths of employees in Weyburn
SaskPower was sentenced Friday morning in a Weyburn courtroom, receiving a record fine, after being found guilty of three workplace-safety related violations when two experienced employees were killed on the job in 2020.
Trump compares jailed U.S. Capitol rioters to Japanese internment during Second World War
Former U.S. president Donald Trump on Friday compared the people jailed on charges that they stormed the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, to the more than 120,000 people of Japanese origin incarcerated on U.S. soil during World War II.
Thousands of hybrid vehicles recalled in Canada over risk of fire
An increased risk of fire has prompted the recall of thousands of Honda hybrid vehicles in Canada.
Tobacco settlement will not protect future generations from addiction: advocates
The Canadian Cancer Society says a proposed settlement that may see tobacco companies pay out billions of dollars would do little to prevent future generations from becoming addicted to smoking.
'Just unbelievable': Video shows wild incident at B.C. frozen yogurt shop
Police were called to a frozen yogurt shop in Richmond, B.C., Wednesday after a man went behind the counter and scooped some of the product with his hand.
These are the top trending Halloween costumes in Canada, according to Google
According to Google search data, the top Halloween costumes trending in Canada include everything from Taylor Swift for kids to the Joker and Harley Quinn for couples.
Defence minister announces nearly $65 million in aid to Ukraine
National Defence Minister Bill Blair says Canada is sending $64.8 million in military aid to Ukraine.