Three of Ontario's four main parties say they favour electoral reform
Three of Ontario's four main parties are promising to change the province's electoral system, a lofty goal some political science experts say may not come to pass.
The NDP and Greens favour forms of proportional representation, while Liberal Leader Steven Del Duca has pledged to step down if his party forms government but doesn't bring in a preferential ballot system after a year.
Only Progressive Conservative Leader Doug Ford has remained silent on the issue, though he's indicated that he's not inclined to overhaul the electoral system.
"We need politicians and leaders to figure out how to collaborate more, to work across party lines, instead of being stuck in the old way of doing things," Del Duca said at a campaign stop in Thunder Bay, Ont., on Sunday. "Doug Ford might want us to be stuck back there and trying to drag people backwards, but we want to make sure that our political system -- our democracy, how we choose our parties and our leaders -- is keeping pace with the time."
But Cristine de Clercy, an associate professor of political science at Western University, said that while electoral reform is a popular topic on the campaign trail, it's easier to talk about change than actually enact it.
"If we look at the history of electoral reform across the last 20 years in Canada at the provincial level, the evidence is not positive for the likelihood that we will achieve electoral reform even within the next 20 years," she said.
British Columbia has held several referenda on the issue, but de Clercy noted proposals for change have not borne fruit.
The federal Liberal government, too, has promised electoral reform and failed to deliver.
Justin Trudeau ran on the pledge in 2015, saying that the federal election held that year would be the last to use the first-past-the-post method, a pledge he would ultimately renege on.
Under the system, voters pick one candidate in their riding and the person with the most votes wins. The successful candidate doesn't need to win a majority of votes to take the riding.
Ford's campaign did not immediately respond to a request for comment on electoral reform, but de Clercy said there are good reasons to stick with the first-past-the-post system.
"Ontario has a competitive multiparty system," she said. "If we brought in electoral reform that looked much more like pure proportional representation it would be very unlikely that we would have any majority governments going forward. So we would be perpetually in a state of minority government, which is inherently unstable because at any point the coalitions can crumble and we're back to the polls."
She said it also makes sense for Ford to hesitate on electoral reform given the nature of his party.
"The Conservative Party ideologically tends to be the party of tradition in Canadian politics," she noted.
The three other parties have said the current system just doesn't pass muster.
Andrea Horwath's NDP are in favour of a mixed member proportional voting system, which tries to lend some of the stability of the first-past-the-post system to a fully proportional government.
Under the NDP's proposed system, some legislators would be elected in local districts and others would be elected for the whole province from party lists.
The system was designed by the Ontario Citizens' Assembly on Electoral Reform, which a previous Liberal government established in 2006.
"It's the people of Ontario really, in the constituency assembly, that recommended the mixed member proportional system, and that's why we embraced it," Horwath said Saturday.
But when the proposal was brought to a referendum in the 2007 election, the province voted against it.
The Green Party, meanwhile, prefers a fully proportional system but suggests in its platform that it would create a "diverse, randomly selected" citizens assembly, this time with a mandate to create binding recommendations.
Tim Abray, a teaching fellow and PhD candidate in political studies at Queen's University, said the proportional system tends to be popular because it allows people to feel like their vote really counts.
"Proportional systems, there is no question. They do a much better job of representing the breadth and diversity of vote choices across the jurisdiction," he said.
He's also hesitant to buy into the idea that proportional systems lead to unstable governments, saying instead that they lead to more compromise.
"The system forces elected representatives into conversation with one another to broker solutions, rather than using the bully pulpit of majority governments to just push through whatever agenda the governing party chooses to put in place," Abray said.
But still, he's not confident that Ontario's system will really change. Polls suggest the Progressive Conservatives are in the lead, and if the NDP manage to eke out a win, it's unlikely they'd get the majority they need to adopt a proportional system.
As for the Liberals, Abray said, he doesn't see their proposal of a ranked ballot as true reform because it doesn't change how people are represented in government.
With that system, voters mark their first, second and subsequent choices. If no candidate wins more than 50 per cent of the vote, the contender with the fewest votes is dropped from the ballot and their supporters' second choices are counted. That continues until one candidate emerges with a majority.
"It's pretty much identical to first-past-the-post in that it will continue to elect people who do not have the backing of the majority of the people within their jurisdiction," Abray said.
All three left-leaning parties have said they would bring back the option for municipalities to use ranked ballots -- the same system the Liberals favour provincewide.
It was an option for municipalities for the first time in 2018, but no longer.
Ford's Progressive Conservatives scrapped the possibility in 2020 in a move Horwath described as "ham-fisted."
This report by The Canadian Press was first published May 22, 2022.
-with files from Jessica Smith in Thunder Bay, Ont., and Maan Alhmidi in Toronto
Toronto Top Stories
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
The Bank of Canada's strategy of rapidly increasing its key interest rate in an effort to tackle skyrocketing inflation will likely trigger a recession, a new study from the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives (CCPA) says.
A shooter fired on an Independence Day parade from a rooftop in suburban Chicago, spraying the crowd with gunshots initially mistaken for fireworks before hundreds of panicked revellers of all ages fled in terror. At least six people were killed and at least 30 wounded.
As Canadian airports continue to experience long lines, cancelled flights and even lost luggage, travel expert Natalie Preddie says there still are ways to ensure a less stressful airport experience.
The 17-year-old daughter of the Toronto Blue Jays' first base coach died in a 'terrible accident' while tubing in the U.S. this weekend.
A day after Russian President Vladimir Putin declared victory in seizing an eastern Ukraine province essential to his wartime aims, the mayor of a city in the path of Moscow's offensive warned residents Tuesday to evacuate ahead of an expected assault.
Two climate change protesters were arrested after they glued themselves to the frame of a famous John Constable painting hanging in Britain's National Gallery, the central London museum and police said.
Tamara Lich, an organizer of the 'Freedom Convoy,' is set to appear in an Ottawa court today for a bail hearing after being arrested last week for allegedly breaching one of her bail conditions.
Simple advice from a friend to stay near the door may have saved Yenifer Yulisa Cardona Tomás from the deadly fate that befell 53 other migrants when they were abandoned trapped in a sweltering semi-trailer last week on the edge of San Antonio. The 20-year-old from Guatemala's capital said it was already hot on June 27 when she stepped out of the warehouse on the Texas side of the Mexico border where she had been waiting and climbed into the back of the trailer.
The 30 NATO allies signed off on the accession protocols for Sweden and Finland on Tuesday, sending the membership bids of the two nations to the alliance capitals for legislative approvals -- and possible political trouble in Turkey.
Two young emergency room doctors, raised and trained in Montreal, are leaving their jobs after only two years to move back to Toronto – and they say the Quebec health-care model and Bill 96 are to blame.
Quebec is reporting another jump in COVID-19 cases on Tuesday as the province records 20 more deaths and 147 additional hospitalizations in the last 24 hours.
Until now, Quebec has required patients to have ultrasounds before getting the pills that induce a medical abortion. In the rest of Canada, that measure was abandoned in 2019.
OPP in Elgin County are hoping somebody may have some footage of vandals.
Huron County OPP are investigating a fatal single vehicle crash that occurred west of Exeter late Monday afternoon.
A 43-year-old Chatham man is facing several charges after reports of a stabbing and shots fired in Chatham.
What ended up being a false alarm saw Waterloo regional police respond to a weapons call at a Kitchener encampment with guns drawn on Saturday.
'The interest just completely faded after the arrest': Cambridge teen’s dream of going to NHL derailed by bullying, harassment, alleges lawsuit
A Cambridge family has launched a $5.5-million civil lawsuit against Victus Academy, an elite hockey prep school in Kitchener, and three of its students.
Up in smoke: Recent cannabis store closures in Uptown Waterloo could be signs of oversaturated market
Cannabis shops cropped up quickly across Waterloo region, but it seems some are now closing shop shortly after they arrived. At least one expert says the shift could point to signs of saturation as the heavily competitive fight for cannabis sales takes its toll.
At a special meeting of United Steelworkers Local 2251, membership backed its negotiating team in talks with Algoma Steel with a strike authorization vote of 99% Monday, the union said in a release.
Highland Park's police chief said the 22-year-old man identified as a person of interest in the shooting that killed at least six people, wounded at least 30 and sent hundreds of people fleeing from an Independence Day parade in suburban Chicago on Monday has been taken into custody.
Former Saskatchewan premier Brad Wall was in contact with a key organizer of the Freedom Convoy anti-mandate protest, providing strategic advice before and after the Ottawa occupation began, according to court records obtained by CTV News.
An elderly woman has died after being hit by a garbage truck Monday morning.
Ottawa Public Health says Ottawa is entering a new wave of COVID-19, saying indicators show a rising level of transmission in the community.
The 12 days of trial running that Ottawa’s Stage 1 LRT line had to go through has become the focus of the Ottawa Light Rail Transit Public Inquiry as it nears the end of public hearings.
A 43-year-old Chatham man is facing several charges after reports of a stabbing and shots fired in Chatham.
The average house price and sales are declining in the region, according to the Windsor-Essex County Association of Realtors.
Hot and humid conditions continue Tuesday in Windsor-Essex, Sarnia-Lambton, Elgin and London Middlesex as a heat warning remains in effect.
The OPP is releasing a video in the hope of solving a murder that occurred near Midland one year ago.
Chase Mariano's family left their east Barrie home for less than two hours and returned to find a broken window, bedrooms torn apart and a lot of valuable jewelry missing.
A day after a Nova Scotia woman shared her story about driving her son to the hospital after waiting for an ambulance, her provincial politician is calling for better services and accountability.
Whether its airlines, airports, or the federal government’s ArriveCan app, who to blame for the chaos facing Canada’s travel industry continues to be a question for thousands of passengers.
Hopes for the return of a beloved international tradition between St. Stephen, N.B., and Calais, Maine, have once again been sidelined due to pandemic land border restrictions.
A 27-year-old man has been charged with first-degree murder in connection with a death at the McDonald's in Sundre, Alta. early Monday morning.
Calgary councillors are scheduled to debate and vote on a 99-page climate strategy.
WEATHER | Calgary warms up, still a risk of storms
Afternoon storm risk in Calgary Tuesday and Wednesday.
A section of Winnipeg’s Main Street is closed on Tuesday morning due to a “serious” incident that left one person in critical condition, according to police.
LIVE @ 11 AM
The Winnipeg Police Service is giving an update on an investigation into a man who was last seen in January 2021.
A pair of longstanding buildings in Winnipeg’s Osborne Village are set to be demolished beginning on Tuesday.
A man is dead and an investigation is underway after a shooting at a Surrey hotel.
A recent browse of real estate listings in Vancouver showed that several mansions in one particular area of the city are for sale.
A young woman who was on life support following a crash on a British Columbia highway has died, officials say.
Periods of steadier, light rain are making their way across the Edmonton region and much of central and north-central Alberta this morning.
An Edmonton flight bound for Halifax never made it to its destination after a landing gear sustained damage during takeoff Monday afternoon.
Two people are in hospital with gunshot wounds after a drive-by shooting in northeast Edmonton Monday evening.