Reactions pour in over Toronto officer promoted decades after killings, beating of Black men
Reactions pour in over Toronto officer promoted decades after killings, beating of Black men
The controversial history of a Toronto police officer in the 1990s is still relevant today and should have been considered during a decision to promote him to lead the Toronto Police Service’s (TPS) professional standards unit, critics say.
“It stinks to high hell. It’s extremely disappointing and it erodes the public trust,” said Nigel Barriffe, the president of the Urban Alliance on Race Relations. “This is a call on the Toronto Police Services Board to reverse the decision.”
Walied Khogali Ali of the Regent Park Neighbourhood Association said at an unrelated press conference that he was concerned Shank’s assignment didn’t reflect the sensitivity to systemic racism in the police force that former Chief James Ramer showed in an apology last year.
“I believe apologies are meaningless unless there is action behind that apology. We’re looking for the leadership of the Toronto Police Service to demonstrate through action what they meant by that apology,” Ali said.
“I think the Toronto Police Service needs to re-examine how they want to build a relationship with the community.”
The professional standards unit for Toronto police is responsible for internal investigations, liaising with police watchdogs including the Special Investigations Unit (SIU), and strengthening public confidence in the police.
The SIU cleared then-Const. Rick Shank when he shot and killed 20-year-old Ian Coley in 1993. The agency charged him with manslaughter for killing Hugh Dawson in 1997 — a charge that first resulted in a hung jury and then an acquittal.
The SIU didn’t prosecute Shank for the alleged beating of 29-year-old Paul Reece in 1993, saying the impact on the young man didn’t rise to its level of “serious injuries.” Shank faced no internal discipline proceedings in that incident, though a lawsuit by Reece reportedly ended in a settlement and the charges against Reece were thrown out of court.
There is no mention of that history in a letter to the TPS Board in 2021, when former Chief James Ramer said simply of a group of officers, including Shank, “A check of internal sources, including Professional Standards, Diversity and Inclusion, Legal Services and Labour Relations, reveals no historic or current information on file indicating that the officers should not be recommended for a promotion.”
The letter says the hiring panel included soon-to-be Chief Myron Demkiw, who has faced his own controversy about his involvement in a Toronto bathhouse raid in 2000.
Each city councillor who sits on the TPS Board referred CTV News Toronto to the board chair.
The board chair said in a statement that any promotion involving Shank is mandated to have met the requirements as set out in its procedures.
“It recognizes that service members may, from time to time, be involved in incidents which merit scrutiny, concern, complaints or charges (whether disciplinary or criminal), and ensures that the process is structured so that these affect promotional opportunities in appropriate cases, while also allowing for the fact that in some circumstances the outcome — such as acquittal, allegations concluded to be unfounded, no laying of charges — is such that a promotion can proceed. The procedure also ensures that the totality of a service member’s work is considered when determining opportunities for promotion,” the statement on behalf of its interim chair, Lisa Kostakis, said.
TPS has said that the incidents in the 1990s do not reflect who Shank is as a person and a police officer, and have pointed to what they call 30 years of exemplary service.
Former TPS Board Member Alok Mukherjee said the board and the chief must go beyond considering the simple procedure, and must critically examine how their decisions will be seen by the community at large.
“What does it say about the Chief’s sensitivity to the issue of community trust in the internal investigation process with someone like this being the head?” he asked.
He said regardless of the information which was in the package, the board must also do its own research.
“The boards need to do more due diligence. They really need to dig much deeper into the history of someone they are considering for higher office,” he said.
Louis March of the Zero Gun Violence Movement said the appointment left him “scratching his head” because of the previous commitments to building healthy relationships with the Black community.
“If he’s going to be head of the standards, his standards is not similar to what the city wants,” March said.
Fires across the country are burning millions of hectares of land but what does that really look like? CTVNews.ca compared the blazes to some cities and lakes in the country showing just how big they have gotten.
Former U.S. president Donald Trump is facing 37 felony charges related to the mishandling of classified documents, according to an indictment unsealed Friday that alleges that he described a Pentagon 'plan of attack' and shared a classified map related to a military operation.
Former U.K. Prime Minister Boris Johnson shocked Britain on Friday by quitting as a lawmaker after being told he will be sanctioned for misleading Parliament.
Despite the alarming facts and figures, experts say Canada is far more reactive than it is proactive when it comes to wildfires and they’re calling for a national campaign on wildfire education to better prepare for the future.
Showers are predicted Saturday over the aggressive wildfire threatening Tumbler Ridge, but forecasters say thunderstorms could sweep through the parched region without bringing any rain.
Air Canada says it made a mistake in rejecting some compensation claims from the thousands of travellers affected by delayed flights due to computer malfunctions.
Montreal police (SPVM) stats for 2022 show that crime went up dramatically in 2022 and, taking COVID-19 pandemic numbers into account, violent crimes have been on the rise overall since 2017. In addition, motor vehicle thefts skyrocketed, having more than doubled since pre pandemic years.
A chain of illegal magic mushroom dispensaries in Ontario is determined to open a location in Montreal this summer despite the threat of a crackdown by Mayor Valerie Plante.
Police have shut down a section of Highway 401 westbound between Woodstock and Cambridge after a crash involving a transport truck and an Ontario Ministry of Transportation (MTO) vehicle.
Poor air quality in Temiskaming Shores forced the hospital to cancel all surgeries Friday, and depending on the forest fire situation, it may have to cancel more procedures scheduled Monday.
A tenant displaced in the downtown Sudbury fire last month said her hotel is denying her request to move her room to a centralized location following an attempted break-in.
Hundreds of counter-protesters gathered near three schools in Ottawa's west end on Friday to take a stand against a B.C. man who is protesting what he calls "gender ideology."
The Sir John A. Macdonald Parkway in Ottawa's west end will be renamed Kichi Zībī Mīkan, if approved by the National Capital Commission's board of directors.
Provincial police with the Bracebridge detachment say a 15-year-old boy, 12-year-old girl, and seven-year-old girl who were reported missing have been found safe.
Nova Scotia says it has identified more details about the records stolen in a file transfer service cyber attack, impacting teachers, students and health care workers' records.
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith named her new cabinet Friday, about two weeks after her United Conservative Party took the majority of seats in Alberta.
Winnipeg police say a woman is in hospital with severe injuries after she was allegedly stabbed by a man in what police describe as a completely random and unprovoked attack.
Weekly wastewater surveillance data from the B.C. Centre for Disease Control suggests COVID-19 transmission has continued declining in the Lower Mainland this month, a week after the centre reported its lowest hospitalization total in nearly two years.
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith named her new cabinet Friday, about two weeks after her United Conservative Party took the majority of seats in Alberta.
