Ontario schools in low-risk communities should scrap COVID-19 restrictions like distancing and cohorting, experts say
Schools in communities with a low number of COVID-19 hospitalizations should be able to forgo physical distancing and cohorting in the fall while adopting a more relaxed approach when it comes to masking and screening students for symptoms, according to a new paper being released by Ontario’s science table.
The paper, which was prepared by a Sick Kids led group of experts, argues that schools should remain open for in-person learning “barring catastrophic circumstances” and that extracurricular activities should be prioritized as “an important component of return-to-school plans.”
The 41-page report does say that temporary school-based measures to prevent the spread of COVID-19 should continue for the time being but it suggests that they should be imposed differently depending on the level of “community COVID-19 burden” rather than transmission.
The expert recommendations are based on three different scenarios – one in which there is only “limited and sporadic cases” of severe disease, another in which there is “early evidence” of an upward trajectory in severe disease and a third with a high prevalence of severe disease and a continued upward trajectory in hospitalizations.
In the best-case scenario, they say that contact tracing and low-barrier testing would serve “as an early warning system for emerging variants and increased transmission,” allowing for schools to return to something more closely approaching the pre-pandemic normal.
That means there would be no requirement for distancing or cohorting, though the experts say that class sizes “should still be kept as small as possible” and that classroom mixing should only occur outdoors.
In moderate and high-risk scenarios, the experts are recommending a return to physical distancing in the classroom but only for older students. For younger students, they say that “cohorting and masking” should be emphasized instead “to allow for close interactions.”
The experts do not take a position on making vaccines mandatory for eligible students and staff at schools but do say that schools and school boards should be given access to “anonymized and aggregated information” on vaccine uptake to support targeted education and improved accessibility.
“I think the take home message really is that we have thought about a framework and guidance under the assumption that number one children have to be in school starting in September and have to stay in school, which is really the essential workplace for children,” Dr. Ronald Cohn, the president and CEO at The Hospital for Sick Children, told CP24 on Monday afternoon. “We need to ensure that children can stay in school and only under catastrophic circumstances should we use school closures as a measure to control the pandemic.”
SCHOOL ACTIVITIES SHOULD MOSTLY RESUME WITH PRECAUTIONS
The paper released on Monday goes into significant detail about the harm caused to students by prolonged school closures, citing research which suggests that only 15 to 60 per cent of learning loss could be mitigated through remote learning.
The paper says that there is also “significant evidence” that the closures have had an impact on the physical and mental wellbeing of children with high rates of anxiety and depression being observed.
The experts say that students should be greeted by a more normal school environment in the fall with the resumption of many activities that were put on hold this year.
That means that assemblies can resume in “low risk communities” while remaining online only in “high risk communities.” Intramural sports and competitive sports, meanwhile, can be held both outdoors and indoors in low-risk communities but in high-risk communities they should be outdoors-only.
Cafeteria closures are not recommended for any of the scenarios but the experts say that in high risk communities additional measures such as staggered lunch breaks and shorter lunch times could be put into place to reduce the risk of transmission.
“The past was dominated by using schools or school closure as a blunt tool for pandemic control. That should not happen anymore. We should make that history,” Dr. Peter Juni, the scientific director of Ontario's science advisory table, told CP24. “I think we had real consensus on the harms done to our kids (from school closures). Ontario actually had the longest deviation from in-person learning in Canada and we were probably also relatively world leaning on that one and that is not a good place to be. Next time we are in situations where new need to fine tune our response it shouldn’t be schools that have to stay closed or become closed.”
The Ford government has not yet released its plan for the resumption of classes but Education Minister Stephen Lecce has previously suggested that one will be made public sometime this month.
In a statement issued on Monday afternoon, Lecce said that his government is “following the advice of Sick Kids and paediatric experts” when it comes to the return to class and has already invested $1.6 billion in keeping students safe.
He said that the back-to-school plan will “will work to ensure a more normal in-class learning experience” in September, including the resumption o extracurricular activities. He did not, however, specifically address the dozens of recommendations made by the Sick Kids-led panel.
OTHER HIGHLIGHTS FROM THE PAPER:
• Symptoms screening as students arrive for school should only be considered in high-risk communities
• The symptom list should be narrowed in low-risk communities to focus on ones more commonly associated with COVID-19
• Fully vaccinated students who develop symptoms should also be exempted from a previous policy requiring that they isolate for 14 days or test negative for COVID-19.
• Asymptomatic testing of students is not recommended in low or moderate risk communities and should be further studied for high-risk communities due to “substantial logistical and equity concerns.”
• The definition of high-risk contacts should be reconsidered to minimize disruption to in-person learning
• Masking should be optional in low-risk communities but is recommended in moderate and high-risk communities
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
CRA no longer requiring 'bare trust' reporting in 2023 tax return
The Canada Revenue Agency announced Thursday it will not require 'bare trust' reporting from Canadians that it introduced for the 2024 tax season, just four days before the April 2 deadline.
He didn't trust police but sought their help anyway. Two days later, he was dead
Jameek Lowery was among more than 330 Black people who died after police stopped them with tactics that aren’t supposed to be deadly, like physical restraint and use of stun guns, The Associated Press found.
Fluid in eye cells can 'boil' if you watch the eclipse without protection: expert
Millions of people in parts of Eastern and Atlantic Canada will be able to see the rare solar eclipse happening on April 8. But they should only look up if they have proper eye protection, experts say.
NEW More unauthorized products for skin, sexual enhancement, recalled: Here are the recalls of this week
Health Canada and the Canadian Food Inspection Agency recalled various items this week, including torches, beef biltong and unauthorized products related to skin care and sexual enhancement.
Where is the worst place for allergy sufferers in Canada?
The spring allergy season has started early in many parts of Canada, with high levels of pollen in some cities already. Experts weigh in on which areas have it worse so far this season.
Do these exercises for core strength if you can't stomach doing planks
Planks are one of the most effective exercises for strengthening your midsection, as they target all of your major core muscles: the transverse abdominis, rectus abdominis, external obliques and internal obliques. Yet despite the popularity of various 10-minute plank challenges, planking is actually one of the most dreaded core exercises, according to many fitness experts.
Grandparent scam: London, Ont., senior beats fraudsters not once, but twice
It was a typical Tuesday for Mabel Beharrell, 84, until she got the call that would turn her world upside down. Her teenaged grandson was in trouble and needed her help.
Angst and calls for resting places as Surrey, B.C., pet cemetery development continues
A single headstone is all that remains of dozens of markers for long-buried pets in a subdivision in Surrey’s Newton neighbourhood, where a half-acre parcel bears a large sign announcing the proposed construction of new homes.
Polar ice is melting and changing Earth's rotation. It's messing with time itself
One day in the next couple of years, everyone in the world will lose a second of their time. Exactly when that will happen is being influenced by humans, according to a new study, as melting polar ice alters the Earth’s rotation and changes time itself.