Judges quash OPP’s decision that officer misconduct in fatal crash was 'not serious'
A panel of Ontario judges has thrown out a decision by the Ontario Provincial Police that an officer’s misconduct behind the wheel that killed a pedestrian in 2020 was not serious, saying the force must reconsider, and at least explain its decision to his grieving widow.
The decision could introduce new standards of transparency in cases of Ontario police misconduct, after a CTV News investigation found the OPP had written multiple letters with identical paragraphs that did not explain to complainants why it had found misconduct “not serious.”
In this case, Courtney D’Arthenay, who was seeking answers in her husband Tyler Dorzyk’s death, got a boilerplate letter. Instead, the OPP should have given reasons, the panel of judges wrote.
“A complainant has a legitimate expectation of receiving reasons justifying why conduct is not “of a serious nature” when the officer’s conduct caused a civilian death,” wrote the panel, which consisted of Justices Fitzpatrick, O’Brien, and Cullin.
“It will not be readily apparently to many members of the public how police misconduct causing death is not considered serious. At a minimum, there is a legitimate expectation in having this explained,” the panel wrote.
D’Arthenay said in an interview she believes her husband would be proud.
“He’d be pleased that he has this legacy and it will help people going through this,” she said. “We both believe in standing up for what’s right.”
D’Arthenay’s lawyer, Justin Safayeni, said the court’s message is that transparency and accountability in police disciplines are important principles that must be respected.
“Hopefully if the decision is taken seriously it means there won’t be another case like Courtney’s. No more boilerplate decisions that don’t explain why the force reaches the decision it did,” Safayeni said.
Dorzyk died just after midnight on September 28, 2020, when he and a friend were walking across Highway 12 at Jones Road in Midland, Ontario. He was travelling to the city for work and crossed against the light in the rain in the dark.
An investigation found Const. Jaimee McBain was driving an unmarked SUV, returning from getting coffee for another officer at a crime scene. She told investigations she didn’t see Dorzyk. She turned the vehicle around and tried to revive him.
McBain wasn’t charged criminally, though a police watchdog found she committed discreditable conduct, speeding between 72 and 97 km per hour even though the speed limit had dropped from 80 km per hour to 60 km per hour in the run-up to the intersection where the crash occurred.
Because the watchdog didn’t specify whether the misconduct was serious, that allowed the OPP to make the decision, which denied D'Arthenay the ability to attend a hearing and narrowed the scope of punishment for the officer.
But the judges rejected a call from D’Arthenay to make a decision from the bench that the misconduct was serious.
“The record provides material that could be used to support either conclusion about seriousness,” the judges wrote, pointing to reasonable grounds that McBain operated he vehicle dangerously, but also that her transgression was “close to the line”.
James Girvin, who represented McBain in the hearing, wrote in an email he is disappointed and didn’t believe that the court followed precedent.
“In doing so the court has created procedural obligations for the Commissioner/Chiefs that is outside of the legislature’s intent when they crafted the Police Services Act. I will be discussing the decision with PC McBain and the OPP regarding consideration of seeking a review of the court’s decision,” Girvin wrote.
CTV News has reached out to the OPP for comment on what steps it will take in light of the ruling.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Canadian family stuck in Lebanon anxiously awaits flight options amid Israeli strikes
A Canadian man who is trapped in Lebanon with his family says they are anxiously waiting for seats on a flight out of the country, as a barrage of Israeli airstrikes continues.
Yazidi woman captured by ISIS rescued in Gaza after more than a decade in captivity
A 21-year-old Yazidi woman has been rescued from Gaza where she had been held captive by Hamas for years after being trafficked by ISIS.
Scientists looked at images from space to see how fast Antarctica is turning green. Here's what they found
Parts of icy Antarctica are turning green with plant life at an alarming rate as the region is gripped by extreme heat events, according to new research, sparking concerns about the changing landscape on this vast continent.
DEVELOPING 2 dead after fire rips through historic building in Old Montreal
At least two people are dead and others are injured after a fire ripped through a century-old building near Montreal's City Hall, sources told Noovo Info.
Suspect in shooting of Toronto cop was out on bail
A 21-year-old man who was charged with attempted murder in the shooting of a Toronto police officer this week was out on bail at the time of the alleged offence, court documents obtained by CTV News Toronto show.
A 6-year-old girl was kidnapped in Arkansas in 1995. Almost 30 years later, a suspect was identified
Nearly 30 years after a six-year-old girl disappeared in Western Arkansas, authorities have identified a suspect in her abduction through DNA evidence.
Dolphins 'smile' at each other when they play and to avoid misunderstanding, study finds
For humans, flashing a smile is an easy way to avoid misunderstanding. And, according to a new study, bottlenose dolphins may use a similar tactic while playing with each other.
Haitian gang kills at least 70 people, including 3 infants, UN says
Armed men belonging to the Gran Grif gang killed at least 70 people, including three infants, as they swept through a Haitian town shooting automatic rifles at residents, a spokesperson for the United Nations' Human Rights Office said on Friday.
Pit bulls in B.C. pet mauling tested positive for meth, cocaine, says city
Three pit bulls involved in a deadly attack on another dog last month in Kamloops, B.C., tested positive for methamphetamine and cocaine, and the city is going to court to have them put down.