Judges quash OPP’s decision that officer misconduct in fatal crash was 'not serious'
A panel of Ontario judges has thrown out a decision by the Ontario Provincial Police that an officer’s misconduct behind the wheel that killed a pedestrian in 2020 was not serious, saying the force must reconsider, and at least explain its decision to his grieving widow.
The decision could introduce new standards of transparency in cases of Ontario police misconduct, after a CTV News investigation found the OPP had written multiple letters with identical paragraphs that did not explain to complainants why it had found misconduct “not serious.”
In this case, Courtney D’Arthenay, who was seeking answers in her husband Tyler Dorzyk’s death, got a boilerplate letter. Instead, the OPP should have given reasons, the panel of judges wrote.
“A complainant has a legitimate expectation of receiving reasons justifying why conduct is not “of a serious nature” when the officer’s conduct caused a civilian death,” wrote the panel, which consisted of Justices Fitzpatrick, O’Brien, and Cullin.
“It will not be readily apparently to many members of the public how police misconduct causing death is not considered serious. At a minimum, there is a legitimate expectation in having this explained,” the panel wrote.
D’Arthenay said in an interview she believes her husband would be proud.
“He’d be pleased that he has this legacy and it will help people going through this,” she said. “We both believe in standing up for what’s right.”
D’Arthenay’s lawyer, Justin Safayeni, said the court’s message is that transparency and accountability in police disciplines are important principles that must be respected.
“Hopefully if the decision is taken seriously it means there won’t be another case like Courtney’s. No more boilerplate decisions that don’t explain why the force reaches the decision it did,” Safayeni said.
Dorzyk died just after midnight on September 28, 2020, when he and a friend were walking across Highway 12 at Jones Road in Midland, Ontario. He was travelling to the city for work and crossed against the light in the rain in the dark.
An investigation found Const. Jaimee McBain was driving an unmarked SUV, returning from getting coffee for another officer at a crime scene. She told investigations she didn’t see Dorzyk. She turned the vehicle around and tried to revive him.
McBain wasn’t charged criminally, though a police watchdog found she committed discreditable conduct, speeding between 72 and 97 km per hour even though the speed limit had dropped from 80 km per hour to 60 km per hour in the run-up to the intersection where the crash occurred.
Because the watchdog didn’t specify whether the misconduct was serious, that allowed the OPP to make the decision, which denied D'Arthenay the ability to attend a hearing and narrowed the scope of punishment for the officer.
But the judges rejected a call from D’Arthenay to make a decision from the bench that the misconduct was serious.
“The record provides material that could be used to support either conclusion about seriousness,” the judges wrote, pointing to reasonable grounds that McBain operated he vehicle dangerously, but also that her transgression was “close to the line”.
James Girvin, who represented McBain in the hearing, wrote in an email he is disappointed and didn’t believe that the court followed precedent.
“In doing so the court has created procedural obligations for the Commissioner/Chiefs that is outside of the legislature’s intent when they crafted the Police Services Act. I will be discussing the decision with PC McBain and the OPP regarding consideration of seeking a review of the court’s decision,” Girvin wrote.
CTV News has reached out to the OPP for comment on what steps it will take in light of the ruling.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Thousands of miles from home, Trudeau learns of dissension in his caucus
The free trade agreement with ASEAN is expected to be signed at the end of 2025. If Trudeau is pressured to step down, or if his government falls and loses the next election, Trudeau will not, as prime minister, be there to see the fruits of his labour.
Court untangles 'bizarre mess' that allowed Vancouver duplex owner to pay off mortgage after foreclosure, sale
A B.C. Supreme Court judge has ruled on a case she describes as a "bizarre mess" in a decision issued earlier this week.
Here's the dirt on the germiest items in your day-to-day life
Your home – considered to be one of the safest havens from all the external stresses – is filthy.
Ottawa bylaw officer struck by driver after altercation in ByWard Market
The woman was taken to hospital and is said to be in stable condition, paramedics say.
Liberals announce new campaign director amid new push to oust Trudeau
The Liberal Party has named Andrew Bevan as its new national campaign director for the next federal election. The announcement comes as party continues to face lagging polls and as party leader Justin Trudeau is facing new pressure to step aside.
Severe weather has some snowbirds leaving Florida, others battening down the hatches
When Julie Riddell and her husband, Gerry, bought their Fort Myers, Fla., vacation property in 2009, it didn't cross their mind that they might be buying in a hurricane-prone area.
Man, 37, stabbed and killed on Montreal metro platform
A man died of his injuries after an altercation that escalated on a platform at Guy-Concordia station on Saturday night.
Trump suggests a protester may get 'the hell knocked out of her' by her parents
Former U.S. president Donald Trump called for a protester at one of his rallies to 'go back home to Mommy' to 'get the hell knocked out of her,' his latest instance of using violent language when confronted by demonstrators.
'Terrifier 3' slashes 'Joker' to take No. 1 at the box office, Trump film 'The Apprentice' fizzles
The choices on the movie marquee this weekend included Joaquin Phoenix as the Joker, a film about Donald Trump, a 'Saturday Night Live' origin story and even Pharrell Williams as a Lego. In the end, all were trounced by an ax-wielding clown.