Judge upholds Ontario rules limiting third-party election ad spending
An Ontario judge has upheld the province's restrictions on third-party election advertising, ruling the measures do not infringe on voters' right to meaningfully participate in the election process.
In a decision issued last week, Ontario Superior Court Justice Ed Morgan threw out the challenge brought forward by a group of labour organizations calling itself the Working Families Coalition.
The coalition challenged the election advertising rules on grounds that they infringe on the right to vote by limiting the ability of third parties to share information on matters of public policy for a year before an election.
Morgan found, however, that the rules meet the legal requirement to allow for broad and egalitarian participation in the campaign.
He noted such restrictions are only required to leave room for third parties to lead informational campaigns -- not to ensure that they can put on an expensive, effective one.
"The object of the exercise is to ensure that the tailoring of the legislation is carefully calibrated with the need for broad and egalitarian participation; it is not to ensure that the political advertisements can pack a strong punch," the judge wrote.
He added there is nothing within the legislation itself that is "politically slanted," as the restrictions apply to all third parties equally.
"While it does limit the pre-writ spending of the applicants, it equally limits the pre-writ spending of their third-party political adversaries," he wrote.
"It may disadvantage them and their allies in the labour movement today, but it may equally disadvantage corporate economic interests tomorrow."
Paul Cavaluzzo, who represents the unions, said his clients are disappointed with the ruling and are reviewing it as they weigh an appeal.
"Their concern is that they don't see how an election can be fair and legitimate when the government, as the judge found, violated their freedom of speech during an election campaign," he said, referencing a previous court challenge against the spending limits.
"As it stands today, the court has found that independent third parties have the constitutional right to run INEFFECTIVE campaigns in an Ontario election. We have trouble believing that that is what is intended by our Charter of Rights and Freedoms and its underlying democratic principles."
In an earlier court challenge, Morgan struck down the spending limits portion of the Election Finances Act on grounds that they infringed on the right to free speech.
The provincial government then invoked the notwithstanding clause to pass Bill 307, which reintroduced amendments to the legislation that had been deemed unconstitutional. The clause allows legislatures to override portions of the charter for a five-year term.
That prompted the coalition to launch a second challenge, this time focusing on the constitutional rights of voters.
The changes brought in by the government double the restricted pre-election spending period for third-party advertisements to 12 months before an election call, but keep the same spending limit of $600,000.
The province argued the changes were necessary to protect elections from outside influence.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Dec. 8, 2021.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Senate expenses climbed to $7.2 million in 2023, up nearly 30%
Senators in Canada claimed $7.2 million in expenses in 2023, a nearly 30 per cent increase over the previous year.
Pedestrian, baby injured after stroller struck and dragged by vehicle in Squamish, B.C.
Police say a baby and a pedestrian suffered non-life-threatening injuries after a vehicle struck a baby stroller and dragged it for two blocks before stopping in Squamish, B.C.
Tom Mulcair: Park littered with trash after 'pilot project' is perfect symbol of Trudeau governance
Former NDP leader Tom Mulcair says that what's happening now in a trash-littered federal park in Quebec is a perfect metaphor for how the Trudeau government runs things.
'It's discriminatory': Individuals refused entry to Ontario legislature for wearing keffiyeh
Individuals being barred from entering Ontario’s legislature while wearing a keffiyeh say the garment is part of their cultural identity— and the only ones making it political are the politicians banning it.
RCMP uncovers alleged plot by 2 Montreal men to illegally sell drones, equipment to Libya
The RCMP says it has uncovered a plot by two men in Montreal to sell Chinese drones and military equipment to Libya illegally.
Government agrees to US$138.7M settlement over FBI's botching of Larry Nassar assault allegations
The U.S. Justice Department announced a US$138.7 million settlement Tuesday with more than 100 people who accused the FBI of grossly mishandling allegations of sexual assault against Larry Nassar in 2015 and 2016, a critical time gap that allowed the sports doctor to continue to prey on victims before his arrest.
Canucks goalie Thatcher Demko won't play in Game 2
The Vancouver Canucks will be without all-star goalie Thatcher Demko when they face the Nashville Predators in Game 2 of their first-round playoff series.
Man wanted in connection with deadly shooting in Toronto tops list of most wanted fugitives in Canada
A 35-year-old man wanted in connection with the murder of Toronto resident 29-year-old Sharmar Powell-Flowers nine months ago has topped the list of the BOLO program’s 25 most wanted fugitives across Canada, police announced Tuesday.
Doctors ask Liberal government to reconsider capital gains tax change
The Canadian Medical Association is asking the federal government to reconsider its proposed changes to capital gains taxation, arguing it will affect doctors' retirement savings.