Judge reserves decision on Hoggard bail attempt as singer seeks SCOC leave to appeal
A justice with Ontario's Appeal Court has reserved her decision on whether Canadian musician Jacob Hoggard should get bail as he tries to appeal his sexual assault conviction at the country's top court.
Justice Jill Copeland heard arguments at a bail hearing for Hoggard on Tuesday morning, weeks after the Hedley frontman began serving his sentence.
Crown prosecutor Catherine Weiler asked Copeland to quash the bail motion, saying the proposed grounds of appeal Hoggard wants to put forward at the Supreme Court of Canada are weak and "unlikely to gain traction."
Arash Ghiassi, a lawyer for Hoggard -- who was not at the hearing -- argued that there is no public interest in keeping the musician behind bars, and the top court has questions of national importance to consider if it decides to hear the case.
In June 2022, a jury found Hoggard guilty of sexual assault causing bodily harm against an Ottawa woman. He was also found not guilty of the same charge and of sexual interference, a charge that refers to the sexual touching of someone under 16, in relation to a teenage fan.
He was later sentenced to five years in prison, and granted bail within hours of the sentencing pending an appeal at Ontario's top court.
Hoggard's lawyers appealed on four grounds, including that the trial judge erred by admitting the evidence of clinical psychologist Lori Haskell on the neurobiology of trauma.
In a unanimous ruling, Ontario's Appeal Court found the trial judge had erred in admitting the expert's evidence in part because it risked being misused by the jury to reason backwards that the trial's two complainants had experienced a sexual assault.
However, the trial judge corrected any potential misuse in answering the jury's questions, and as a result, "there was no substantial wrong or miscarriage of justice," the court found. The court also found the trial judge did not make any errors regarding the other grounds raised in the appeal.
Hoggard began serving his sentence after that Appeal Court decision was handed down last month.
His application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, filed last week, argues that the Appeal Court failed to apply the proper test in deeming the trial judge's error a "harmless" one.
Ghiassi, his lawyer, said in court Tuesday that it is "clearly of a national interest" for the top court to offer clarity on how that test should be handled, and that courts across the country have applied the law inconsistently.
The Crown prosecutor said the assessment on whether a trial judge's error is "harmless" is so case-specific as to be unlikely to garner interest at the highest court.
"It does not clearly surpass the 'not frivolous' criteria and is unlikely to gain traction at the (Supreme Court)," Weiler said of Hoggard's application.
Weiler added that the more serious the crime, the more serious the risk that public confidence in the justice system could be undermined by an offender's release on bail.
Ghiassi asserted there would be no public safety risk to Hoggard's release, noting he has two sureties and a long history of bail compliance.
"The only question is whether it is necessary in the public interest to detain Mr. Hoggard, and it is not," he said.
Ghiassi added Hoggard is in solitary confinement in a correctional institution due to threats to his safety.
Citing a recent information note prepared by the superintendent of the institution, the Crown lawyer said protective custody is voluntary and inmates in protective custody are provided the same out-of-cell time as the general population.
Copeland said she expects to make a decision on bail sometime this week.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Sept. 10, 2024.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
LIVE UPDATES Tracking Hurricane Milton: Storm becomes world's strongest of 2024
After reaching peak intensity with wind speeds of 180 m.p.h. (285 km/h) on Monday night, Milton became the strongest storm on our planet for 2024.
Hurricane Milton expected to hit Florida cities like Tampa, Orlando and Daytona Beach
Hurricane Milton is expected to leave a path of devastation across central Florida, from Tampa in the west to Daytona Beach in the east.
Meteorologist becomes emotional giving update on Hurricane Milton
A seasoned American meteorologist became emotional on air as he gave an update on a major hurricane, later suggesting the reason behind his strong reaction.
Liberals considering proroguing Parliament amid document impasse? Freeland says 'no'
The minority Liberal government is not considering proroguing Parliament, Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland said Tuesday, despite persisting uncertainty over who is willing to keep propping them up and procedural wrangling over a Conservative led-privilege debate.
4 people in Ontario sickened with listeriosis amid beef tongue recall: ministry
The Ontario Ministry of Health says four people have been sickened after consuming beef tongue believed to be contaminated with listeria.
'I hope so': Marc Garneau on whether Liberal party still has room for Blue Liberals
Former cabinet minister Marc Garneau, who describes himself in his new book as always-a-Liberal, 'but a decidedly blue one,' says he hopes the party still has room for someone like him.
'Very' serious issue: federal transport minister on contamination in northern Alberta town
The renewed pleas of people in Fort Chipewyan, Alta. for government to take action cleaning up contamination in their community have reached the ears of federal Transport Minister Anita Anand.
'Extremely disappointed': Family of homicide victim storms out of courtroom as judge reads decision
Emotions boiled over after a judge acquitted two out of three defendants in a manslaughter case, while the third accused has since died.
'I find it really disheartening': Family calls out police after Ottawa senior falls victim to theft in parking lot
On September 11, Madeleine Gervais was the victim of a theft in Ottawa's west end. It happened in the Loblaws parking lot in College Square, when she was approached by a man and a woman who insisted to help her load her groceries into her car.